ABOUT THIS BLOG

Does that new health or fitness product really do what it says it will? Let us find out for you. MSNBC.com writers and editors will periodically try out various products, devices and gadgets and report back their experiences. And experts will help us assess the evidence and spot quack claims. Have an item you'd like us to test? Send an e-mail to health@msnbc.com.



Rise and shine? Well, not exactly

Posted: Thursday, February 28, 2008 3:57 PM

By Julia Sommerfeld, health editor

What it is:  Soleil Sun Alarm, a dawn-simulator alarm clock ($79.99)

Image: Soleil Sun Alarm
gadgetshack.com

What it claims to do:  Gently nudge you awake by gradually increasing the intensity of its built-in light, designed to mimic a sunrise. You can set your fake sun to rise over 15, 30, 60, 90 or 120 minutes. And if you’re a deep sleeper you can end your sun rise cycle with the back-up beeper, radio or strobe light. The maker claims that waking up to light resets your internal clock, making it easier to rise on subsequent mornings.

My experience:  In the interest of full disclosure, let me say that I’m nocturnal by nature and have never met an alarm clock I like. Whether they beep, make soothing rainforest sounds or blare my very favorite song, I find alarm clocks to be singularly sadistic; it’s a cruel irony that it takes three of them to wake me every morning.

So you can understand why I was hopeful about the sun alarm’s promises of a kinder, gentler start to my day.

Boy was I in for a rude awakening.

I set the sunrise for the standard half-hour cycle, ending with a back-up beeper and strobe light at 6 a.m., just in case the simulated sunshine didn’t do the trick.

But instead of waking up peaceably to the early glow of the simulated morning light – which I completely missed because my internal night owl grabbed a pillow and covered my face – I awoke to my Pomeranian marching in place on my chest and barking at my pillowed face. When I uncovered an eye, I discovered that the sun alarm was approaching peak intensity. I felt like I was in the white flash scene from one of those nuclear holocaust movies. Half-blinded, I could only make out a fluffy outline doing some sort of panicked gymnastics routine all over the bed, ending with a dive roll on my husband’s head. He started shouting at the dog, but as soon as he opened his eyes and discovered that the dog was simply trying to alert us to the fact that a nuclear bomb had gone off in our bedroom, he started shouting at me. To add to the pandemonium, the back-up alarm and strobe light kicked on.

The good news is I got up, walked the dog and even got to work early. The bad news: My husband was mad at me all morning.

This scene was pretty much repeated every morning for a week, except I skipped the strobe light finale for fear of inducing seizures. (After Day 1, my husband said I had exactly one week to finish my business with this alarm clock or else he was moving out.)

But as it turns out, even unplugged and stashed in a drawer, the sun alarm is the gift that keeps on giving.

The clock’s maker claims that the dawn-simulator helps reset your biological clock and can transform you into a morning person. That didn’t seem to work for me; mornings are still as difficult as ever. As for the dog, she’s woken up every morning since at 5:30 a.m., bright-eyed and bushy-tailed.

What the expert says:  “For someone who is naturally a morning person, this is probably a pleasant way to wake up,” says Charmane Eastman, director of the Biological Rhythms Research Lab and a professor at Rush University in Chicago. “But the type of person who has trouble waking up isn’t going to be transformed; they’ll probably just put a pillow over their face.”

If you’re an intractable night owl hoping to become more of a morning person, waking up to morning light is a bright idea, says Eastman, herself nocturnal by nature. But while the sun alarm’s light source is ominously called a “high intensity Krypton bulb” and certainly felt insanely bright to this user at 6 a.m., a single bulb is not nearly powerful enough to reset your biological clock, Eastman says. For that, you need real sunshine or, if you wake up before dawn, a light-therapy lamp using full-spectrum bulbs.

The best way to train your body to wake up earlier than it likes, Eastman advises, is to always rise at the same time every morning, even on weekends. As soon as you’re up, get outside as soon as possible, go out on the balcony, walk the dog, whatever it takes to get sun on your face and body; this helps convince your body that you are indeed supposed to be awake and helps make future mornings less of a shock to your system.

Bottom line:  If you have trouble getting your dog up in the morning, you might want to get this alarm clock. 


 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I have one of these clocks and I think they are wonderful.. while I'm a morning person anyway.. its makes it much easier to rise and shine !!!!  
I just love this story.  It was very entertaining atleast.  Fortunately mornings aren't horrible for me.  As for my wife who is a homemaker, (and thank God doesn't have to be anywhere in the mornings), it would might require an atomic flash-like device to even begin to stir her before 10am.
That was awesome review!  I have something very similar to this..but mine isn't super bright.  Kind of a bright night light that doesn't get me up any earlier or make it easier.  Its still evil to wake up early and I still hate it.  
I have one of these clocks, had it for over five years now.  I can tell you I love the clock.  In five years time I think I did  not wake on one occasion. The night prior to using the clock I was tending to a dying family member.  So, understandably, the following morning was "unusual" to say the least.

You can get less expensive versions of sunrise clocks through Lands End.  If you are open to trying the clock may I suggest you begin with a less expensive model.

Again, I have had great success with my clock and feel 100% differently than the author of this article.
You'd think living in the "Valley of the Sun" would be enough to alter my nocternal tendencies.  Nope!  I need an interigation lamp blazing in my face every morning.  After I'm evenly roasted the pain usually gets me up.
I was diagnosed with SAD last summer.  I bought a "Lighten Up" timer which I plug my light into.  I set it for 1/2 hour before my alarm goes off.  It has definately helped me...I usually suffer from "the blues" from mid-January to the end of Feb, but have not had that issue at all this year.  It probably helps that I am up after my husband, but without the light, I was constantly sleeping through my alarm and now I don't and I don't feel groggy either when I get up.
I had to wake up at 4:30 AM and my problem was I was blinded and put in a bad mood instantly when I turned on my bed side lamp even though it was a very low wattage bulb.  This lamp saved me and my coworkers.  I love this 'alarm'.  There was only one time that I slept all the way to the music.  It was best buy for me.  
That was just the dose of humor I needed to get me awake this morning.  Perhaps reading reviews written with the same humor as yours is the ultimate alarm clock.
I've had this alarm for about 3 years now.  It takes more than a week to get used to, but it has really helped me during the winter months.  I had tried a lamp on a timer prior to this, and find the gradual increasing intensity of the alarm preferable to a light being flipped on by the timer-even 60 watts seems like mid-day sun in the early morning.  I still use the audible alarm, which is harder to ignore when the light turns back on again.

Of course, I have dogs too, and when they see the first light of the alarm, they start crying to go out.  But it's prefereable to waking up in complete darkness to find your shoes and take them outside.
This article is hilarious.  Great writer!!!
I'm a natural morning person but this is invaluable in the winter when the sun comes up to late.
The thing I have notice with the night owl types is that there isn't an alarm out there that is going to please them because the fact is that they don't want to get up. I am not a morning person but I am at work before the sun rises every day. I think it has gotten a little easier in the past 5 years but I still enjoy sleeping in on the weekends. My trick to getting up early is after I shut the alarm clock off, I flip my feet out of bed and stand up. Thats all there is to it. Once you lay there and snooze it just makes it more difficult.
My wife, on the other hand, is very hard to get up. SHe for some reason can't just shut the alarm off and get out of bed. I have tried a few different alarms. The annoying ones work to get her out of bed but she hates them. why? Well, because they make her get out of bed. I bought the alram that had a helicopter that took off when the alarm went off. She would always have to get out of bed to find it to turn off the alarm. I bet she broke it on pupose.
Okay, well this isn't a very helpful review for the majority of us who don't have dogs. Good to know that my non-existent dog is going to react to this product.
What a humorous review...I laughed out loud! You should try the Zen alarm clock, I LOVE mine.  It uses a single, resonating chime at gradually increasing intervals.  It lets you wake up gradually, without startling you awake like regular alarm clocks.  It was expensive, but one of my best purchases ever.  
I've used a dawn simulator happily for more than two years, but mine is a very simple plug that attaches to a regular lamp.  I use a desk lamp with a full-spectrum bulb, and place it on the other side of the room.  It invariably wakes me without the horrible "jolt" of an alarm clock.  For people like me, who have Seasonal Affective Disorder, a dawn simulator can be a real godsend.
I've used a similar clock from Sharper Image for years and absolutely LOVE it. I hate waking up in the dark which is what happens from November to March where I live. I rarely sleep until the sound alarm goes off. It doesn't use a "krypton" bulb, just a regular, low-wattage bulb and there's no strobe effect.
I have a version of this alarm clock and even though I still struggle to get up in the mornings, I do like the fact that I usually wake up before the alarm sounds.  It's a gentler way to wake up instead of being blasted out of a dead sleep.
I am and always have been a night person. If I could get a job to match my sleep patterns, I would sleep from 2am until 10am, but because I can't I must sleep between 9pm and 5am because of my job. I spent years with insomnia and a couple of years on Lunesta so I could sleep and went to a sleep clinic to try and figure out what was wrong with me.  That said I only went off the Lunesta once I started using a sunset/sunrise alarm clock.  I've used 2 different types (not the one reviewed) with positive results.  I'm up by 5:00 in the morning awake and alert which never happened before using the lamps, and best of all I'm asleep by 10:00.  It has also helped regulate my weekend sleep patterns, so that I no longer sleep too late on the weekends.  Perhaps the model reviewed is not the best, but similar products have cetainly helped me.
This was the most hysterical description of a product I have read in a long time!  I sat at my desk laughing (albeit quietly so others did not think I was insane).  Not sure I want the clock, but the mental images the story painted will last!
Playing in a rock-n-roll band, I was always a "nite-owl".  After I gave that up and moved to a new city, I had to be up at 5am every weekday for work.  Now I have trouble staying awake till 11pm on weekends and have trouble sleeping past 7am.  I HATE IT!  I want to be a nite-owl again!
Perhaps they could market this device to Pomeranians and wives seeking divorce...
I Love It!!  I can just see the dog going nuts in the bed. (My wife takes 3 alarm clocks, too.) Maybe you can re-gift the clock at Christmas.
I had one, and it didn't help me a bit because as soon as I realized it was still dark outside, I went back to bed.  
I need one of these immediately!
Get up everyday at the same time!?  I get up at 4:30 am for work.  I live in the great northwest... I can see it now.  I wake up at 4:30 on a saturday and run out to my balcony in the pouring down rain in the dark IN MY PAJAMAS.  Sounds wonderful :)  I think I'll stick to sleeping in whenever I can...
I'm not a morning person at all, but I have the Sharper Image version of this clock and love it. The light is much gentler than described here, and it adds in a "nature sound" at 15 minutes into the light cycle. (It also has aromatherapy, but I haven't tried that aspect yet.) I do still use the buzzer at the end of the 30-minute light cycle, but by then I'm usually almost awake anyway. It's definitely a much gentler way to wake up than the sudden blaring of a buzzer into a deep sleep!
I only ever use the radio/music portion of alarm clocks. The buzzers are far too jarring and unpleasant (plus they scare the cat into clawing into me).

I've used the Soleil Sun Alarm for about 2 years now, with my local NPR station as my wake-up sound. In the winter, it's great because there's no light outside in the mornings. In the summer, it's a clock radio.

It works best if it's placed at eye-height so the "sun" comes in through your eyelids. If it's not lined up, it's not bright enough to do anything for me. I got new furniture when I moved last year, so this winter it's not quite at eye-height and I totally notice a difference.

It hasn't reset my body clock, but it's a nicer way to wake up than flicking on a lamp.
If you are getting up at 6am then you had better be going to sleep at around 10pm.  Don't blame the alarm clock if you don't get enough sleep to begin with (as your dog definately does).  I have an alarm clock that uses a gradually increasing soft chime - same kind of thing, but it works if you sleep under pillows or covers.  I find that it's only really effective if I allow myself enough sleep time.  But then I am only really effective if I get enough sleep time.
Oh my goodness, this was absolutely the FUNNIEST article I have read in a long time!  I'm sitting at my desk laughing very loudly with tears streaming down my face!  Thank goodness I'm the only one here right now, because everyone would think I've lost my mind!  I would LOVE to read more written by this author, Julia Sommerfeld, if her writings are as funny as this!  The image given of waking up and stumbling around while being, as she said, "blinded from the white flash scene in one of those nuclear-holocaust movies" while a Pomeranian is flipping out and doing gymnastics on the bed will stick with me for some time!
I agree, don't blame the alarm clock, get better sleeping habits. I think the clock is awesome and it works good whemn you spread the light to 30 minutes.
LOL.  Very entertaining, if nothing else.  I am SO glad that I don't have that clock.
For all you nocturnal people, your in for a rude awakening next week when we switch to daylight savings time. Yes we turn our clocks back on the eighth of MARCH. While the sun may set at seven next week, if you wake up at five thirty, as I do, we will be back to the winter doldrums of darkness in the morning. Not that anyone will see this, but good luck to all. Wish I cou;d take the clock to my out-door job.
Even better than a dog or an alarm clock to wake you up in the morning---a baby!!  I have not slept past 6:00 since she was born and now she is 3 years old!!  Talk about a rude awakening!!!
Hilarious!  Thanks for the great review!  Now that is some clock...
Thanks SO much for a hysterically funny article. It's been the week from hell (found out that loved one has to go on chemo), and I REALLY needed that.
I always love when you have people that are exceptions to the rule try out products. If it takes you three alarm clocks to wake up everyday I can assure you your husband will be salty at you every morning regardless of the alarm.
A similar type of analog clock was available in the 50's  from Sunbeam.  My mother bought it around when I was born.  The clock lasted about 40 years.  Several years ago my mother found a modern version of the same clock called "Moon Beam" - exactly the same as the Sunbeam version with the gradually increasing light alarm with the blaring alarm at the end of the wakeup cycle.  She sent it as a present to my wife and I.  I keep it in my den (with the alarm off!!).
Clearly, none of the poor people who struggle to wake up in the mornings have a cat. You can tell a dog to go lay down and be quiet -- and he will eventually, with that "Why me?" look on his face. A cat, on the other hand, has the determination of a rising tide. He will get his way. You WILL get out of bed. -- Fantastic article by Julia Sommerfeld. I laughed out loud.
LOL! As a fellow night owl, I'll be sure to avoid it. :-)
I'm a night owl myself, BUT...

I have a coffee maker with an "Automatic Start" feature.  I started out setting the Coffee Maker to start earlier than my alarm clock, so that the coffee would be ready when the alarm went off.  Much to my amazement, I found that I began awakening to the SMELL of the coffee brewing.  I don't set my alarm at all anymore...
I almost wound up never needing an alarm clock again, started choking with laughter reading this - I want to get this clock just to see what my pom does.
It is pretty cool, you can have the sun shine in your room.
I am still crying even after reading all the comments. Hysterical! Who is this Julia Sommerfield?? I am a night owl myself, and can identify personally with almost every aspect of that story.
I have a psychic and fully clawed male Siamese who can wake me from the deepest sleep by gently sinking his front claws into my chest while licking the end of my nose. In sub-zero winter he uses the little pieces of ice lodged in his paws to enhance the effect.  I suspect the effect is similar to a nuclear Pomeranian but I will accept the writers description as an adequate substitute.  A mere clock you can throw away, but a cat would haunt you to the end of days. Ain't love wonderful
What is a clock?  Is that New Orleans time? Phase out realistic numbers in favor of the real times.
I hope you don't get paid to write. Your review sucks, get another job. The clock appears to be a winner though.
A great read about another trivial product.  You have a talent to amuse. I loved the bit about the nuke going off and upsetting the dog, although it did remind me of what Bush has yet to do. ;-)
If you need 3 alarm clocks to wake your self up, then you're already in a difficult spot.  No alarm clock is gonna make you happy, lol.  I'm a nocturnal person myself, but one alarm is enough for me.  Don't think any alarm is comforting... in a clock, or smoke detector, security...  Good luck in resetting your BIO clock.
I have one of these alarm clocks and it does all it says it will. perhaps you should set it for the 120 minute cycle. however, I don't think anything will work for you as you just don't want to wake up! Everyone likes to blame something/someone else. Try looking in the mirror. That said, I thought your article was rather entertaining and your dog must get a laugh at your antics in the morning.
I have the same clock.  They take some getting used to, but if you use them regularly, they end up resetting and maintaining your sleeping rhythm, so you are actually ready to get up when the light gets to full radiance.  I recently swtiched to the Philips version, which I like even better.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):