ABOUT THIS BLOG

Does that new health or fitness product really do what it says it will? Let us find out for you. MSNBC.com writers and editors will periodically try out various products, devices and gadgets and report back their experiences. And experts will help us assess the evidence and spot quack claims. Have an item you'd like us to test? Send an e-mail to health@msnbc.com.



Rise and shine? Well, not exactly

Posted: Thursday, February 28, 2008 3:57 PM

By Julia Sommerfeld, health editor

What it is:  Soleil Sun Alarm, a dawn-simulator alarm clock ($79.99)

Image: Soleil Sun Alarm
gadgetshack.com

What it claims to do:  Gently nudge you awake by gradually increasing the intensity of its built-in light, designed to mimic a sunrise. You can set your fake sun to rise over 15, 30, 60, 90 or 120 minutes. And if you’re a deep sleeper you can end your sun rise cycle with the back-up beeper, radio or strobe light. The maker claims that waking up to light resets your internal clock, making it easier to rise on subsequent mornings.

My experience:  In the interest of full disclosure, let me say that I’m nocturnal by nature and have never met an alarm clock I like. Whether they beep, make soothing rainforest sounds or blare my very favorite song, I find alarm clocks to be singularly sadistic; it’s a cruel irony that it takes three of them to wake me every morning.

So you can understand why I was hopeful about the sun alarm’s promises of a kinder, gentler start to my day.

Boy was I in for a rude awakening.

I set the sunrise for the standard half-hour cycle, ending with a back-up beeper and strobe light at 6 a.m., just in case the simulated sunshine didn’t do the trick.

But instead of waking up peaceably to the early glow of the simulated morning light – which I completely missed because my internal night owl grabbed a pillow and covered my face – I awoke to my Pomeranian marching in place on my chest and barking at my pillowed face. When I uncovered an eye, I discovered that the sun alarm was approaching peak intensity. I felt like I was in the white flash scene from one of those nuclear holocaust movies. Half-blinded, I could only make out a fluffy outline doing some sort of panicked gymnastics routine all over the bed, ending with a dive roll on my husband’s head. He started shouting at the dog, but as soon as he opened his eyes and discovered that the dog was simply trying to alert us to the fact that a nuclear bomb had gone off in our bedroom, he started shouting at me. To add to the pandemonium, the back-up alarm and strobe light kicked on.

The good news is I got up, walked the dog and even got to work early. The bad news: My husband was mad at me all morning.

This scene was pretty much repeated every morning for a week, except I skipped the strobe light finale for fear of inducing seizures. (After Day 1, my husband said I had exactly one week to finish my business with this alarm clock or else he was moving out.)

But as it turns out, even unplugged and stashed in a drawer, the sun alarm is the gift that keeps on giving.

The clock’s maker claims that the dawn-simulator helps reset your biological clock and can transform you into a morning person. That didn’t seem to work for me; mornings are still as difficult as ever. As for the dog, she’s woken up every morning since at 5:30 a.m., bright-eyed and bushy-tailed.

What the expert says:  “For someone who is naturally a morning person, this is probably a pleasant way to wake up,” says Charmane Eastman, director of the Biological Rhythms Research Lab and a professor at Rush University in Chicago. “But the type of person who has trouble waking up isn’t going to be transformed; they’ll probably just put a pillow over their face.”

If you’re an intractable night owl hoping to become more of a morning person, waking up to morning light is a bright idea, says Eastman, herself nocturnal by nature. But while the sun alarm’s light source is ominously called a “high intensity Krypton bulb” and certainly felt insanely bright to this user at 6 a.m., a single bulb is not nearly powerful enough to reset your biological clock, Eastman says. For that, you need real sunshine or, if you wake up before dawn, a light-therapy lamp using full-spectrum bulbs.

The best way to train your body to wake up earlier than it likes, Eastman advises, is to always rise at the same time every morning, even on weekends. As soon as you’re up, get outside as soon as possible, go out on the balcony, walk the dog, whatever it takes to get sun on your face and body; this helps convince your body that you are indeed supposed to be awake and helps make future mornings less of a shock to your system.

Bottom line:  If you have trouble getting your dog up in the morning, you might want to get this alarm clock. 


 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

My wife has used a simple timer and a light for years its allot cheaper than this thing.  Go to Wal-Mart and ask for a light timer 8.00 - 12.00  bucks.
The "expert" says to re-set your biological clock, wake up and get outside as soon as possible to get sunshine on your body. Well.. the problem with that is.. most people who have to wake up early for work get up BEFORE the sun is up. So that wont help much..
Great review and very humorously written.  Keep up the great reviews and the great writing!
  I had a "Hams Beer Lamp" borrowed from some bar that had a soft blue light plugged into my radio alarm while in the army. I was a nice quiet way to wake in the dark early mornings. This Sun alarm should be great if set not to come on slow.
As one with a profound hearing loss, I have been using a 150 watt clear bulb in a photo lamp (clamp light) for years connected to a "Tork" (max 220 volt 30 amp) electronic timer.  I figured if that didn't work, I was going to hook a 1/2 horsepower electric motor to a belt driven out of balance shafted counterweight with my bed elevated on spring isolators.  If all else fails....I still have my 14 yr old male cat with claws that reminds me when it's time to eat........I would surly  consider running the motor idea past the cat first (that is without me in the bed).
There are a lot more factors in waking up refreshed. Do not eat late, no alcohol and get a solid 7-8 hours.

With that said the story was hilarious!
When I went to the web site for this product and saw a happy, refreshed woman rising to greet the new day I had another great laugh!
This is one of the most entertaining, funny articles I have read in a very long time.
Like the author, I am a night person.  I have slept through trees falling on my house, a house fire and multiple alarm clocks....I would indeed be putting a pillow over my face and this thing would be finding its way to the thrift shop in no time!
Thanks for the laugh!  This was a great article!  I loved it!
I have this alarm clock. I love it! Please don't trash this great product because you are not a morning person.
great article, fun and informative, I think I'll try one since I get up around 3 am it might be nice to wake up to simulated sun light, My body is already adjusted to waking up at that time and my alarm never gets to go off, but I could set this alarm and wake up sunshine
I have one that's similar, different brand.  It is the most natural thing in the world for humans to rise with the sun and fall with the sun.  So, it makes perfect sense.  The one I have also has a feature so that it will "sunset" for 15 minutes.  This gradually lulls you into sleep.

The most favorable thing I can say about these is that it doesn't startle you awake.  Truly, it draws you out, naturally, of your dream cycle... so that you are always your most pleasant self...

peace.
Great article! I'm a two alarm night owl.  One is in the bathroom so I am physically forced to get out of bed to turn it off.  Even so, I will sleep through the piercing alarm for up to 30 minutes and incorporate it into horrible nightmares until I finally wake up.  My solution was to get a dog.  He barks without fail starting at 7AM until I get up to take him out.
I love my Sunrise Alarm Clock!  It slowly takes me out of a deep sleep making me feel more awake when I do wake up.  Of course I back up my sunrise alarm (I back up all my alarm clocks) with two regular alarm clocks (it usually takes me 2 or 3 alarms to wake up regardless of what kind it is).  
what a joke.
i am an Alaskan and not bothered by the darkness or the light.
i always get people asking how i get up in the winter and sleep in the summer.when its time to get up i will and i work hard enough to be tired at the end of my day that sleeping in the light is not an issue.its all in your head.
Kudos to the writer. Wait, let me scroll up as this is one fine scribe and I want to remember her.
Ahhh, that's better. Thank you, Julia Sommerfeld. This article really hit my G-spot...several times.
First, I giggled, enjoyed it, and read on thinking,
mmmm, that was nice. Then, surprise. Once again. Only better. A second giggle was unexpected. Then, again. My, oh my. My eyes opened up a bit. Goodness. Once again. Wow. I started getting flushed. Feeling around the desk for my inhaler, it happened again, and again, and again. Well, you get the idea. I'll look forward to our next exchange. Now THAT'S communication.
My problem with alarm clocks is in turning it off and then going back to sleep, often times doing this unkowingly until I wake up late.  I had to install an alarm bell by the bed with the alarm shutoff in the next room.
That was highly entertaining.

Once upon a time, I saw an alarm clock that I wish I'd bought, as I never saw it again. The clock was contained inside a softball. The way you turned it off was to throw it at something.
The author's delayed sleep phase problems might be adjusted with using a 10,000 lux light early in the morning after waking.  Many people have the genetics for being an owl (late night person) and are helped by resetting their circadian rhythms by light.  For more info go to Dr. Daniel Kripke's website:  brightenyourlife.info.
Julia,
Your writing in this article allowed me to daze off and feel like I was experiencing what you described.
I found myself laughing outloud too and am intrigued to try this "Sun Alarm".  While I can get up to an alarm clock (and my husband is learning), This sounds like a very pleasurable way of waking up.
I shudder to think about either one of my >100 lb. Labs marching on my chest...but am willing to try this alarm to have a more soothing morning. Thank your husband for letting you try it out for the rest of us!
The article was great!!  Thanks for the laugh and thanks for letting me (I'm a nocturnal one) know NOT to buy this alarm clock (I have to set 5 alarms to get up in the morning!)
We used this device to help teach our oldest son to stay in his bed until morning when we had transitioned him out of a crib.  Sure enough, he'd come bounding in to our room at a reasonable time (still before 6am), all excited that his light had come on.  We thought the device was worth the cost and the customer service folks at the company were quite nice.
I laughed almost til I cried!!! Funny!! I thought about buying one of these, except instead of a dog doing doughnuts on me, it will be my 4 year old.
OMG funniest review, couldn't stops laughing, I work at a call center and almost got fired for this... but wow good job :-)
I'm suffering from flu.this article made  me laugh out loud. thank you.
I love the dog and husband reaction.  I have a regular alarm clock that wakes me up - but I wake up my husband because before I'm awake I'm yelling at the clock to shut up!
Hilarious! I also need multiple extremely obnoxious alarm clocks, my problem being that I can get up and turn them off without ever achieving consciousness.  I've resorted to putting alarm clocks scattered around my room and even under my bed in the hopes that the crawling would wake me up!  
Fantastic, entertaining review!  I had to laugh at the mind picture I got thinking about my 2 Yorkies that ALREADY love to awaken early and irritate me until I get moving!  I hate all alarms, I hate getting up (beats the alternative, I guess) so your review was priceless!  Thanks
I ahve long pondered this issue. I invented an alarm clock to dump ice water on you after the second snooze. That will get your donkey out of bed!!!
Hi Julie, very funny article... Enjoyed reading it! I'm a nocturnal person and find it sooo difficult to wake up in the mornings even though I really wish I could wake earlier. Thanks for the article!
Hilarious!  I'm a confirmed enemy of all alarm clocks, myself - having personally demolished several of them in the morning when they wouldn't turn off....

Looks like that won't change, but I laughed and laughed reading the review.  Thanks for the entertainment!
If I wake up facing my window (which has blinds but is still the brightest part of the room), I'll have a near-migrane headache all day from the light.  This alarm sounds like the worst possible option for me.
The only way I can wake up on time is to use my cell phone's MP3 player as an alarm, playing one specific song (You Are The One, by Shiny Toy Guns -- it's perfect), and put the phone in the bathroom so I have to get out of bed to turn it off.
I have also been seen to put a pillow over my head when my Sunrise dawn comes up but I nevertheless I so prefer waking to dawn than noise. A lamp on each side of the bed is lovely. Have considered velcro-ing the pillow in place. (Although going to bed on time seems to fix the errant pillow problem.)
Your review made me laugh out loud and send my kids in the room trying to figure out what could cause such an outburst!  We have 2 pomeranians that usually wake up at 5:30 a.m.  Although I am not a morning person - since I usually don't get to sleep more than a few hours consecutively, I am used to waking up early to let the dogs out.  I have a 7 year old, however, that would sleep through an explosion and is a struggle to wake up every morning for school - even with having 10-12 hours of sleep.  I am definitely going to buy one of these for her room and see if it helps at all.  My only proven alarm for her entails the two poms doing their own "gymnastics" routine on her bed.  That's the one way that gets her awake and laughing at the same time.
I know this is probably too old to respond to...but I was rolling in laughter at the author's description of using this alarm clock.  Construction work in the apartment over mine for 6 mos. ended my morning lateness forever.  I now get to work EARLY.  First time ever in 20 years.
I have a similar clock, and love it! Especially in the months when there is no sunlight in the mornings! My Aunt who suffers from seasonal affective disorder also has one, and says it helps with that too.
Im  at work reading this and laughing histariclly ....Im not a quiet laugher but I am a morning person I dont even need an alarm clock I just wake up 2 to 3 min before it goes off my husband on the other hand would sleep his life away if I didnt wake him up around 1 pm on the weekends . honestly i dont think this would work for anyone who hates to wake up there are just to many ways to get around it ...we sleep under a huge light impermiable blanket .
That was hysterical! But I will say, being a night owl, I have murdered many an alarm clock. Over time I have learned to just wake up naturally, light or not. I wake the same time every day, no problem. It's a training thing.
I have a similar clock that I thought would be a wonderful, peaceful way to wake up; not so much. At first I enjoyed how easily I was awakened by just a little light until I started waking up as soon as the light came on (i.e. 30 minutes EARLY). Not good for someone who hates getting up. I would end up turning of the alarm and oversleeping. It now sits on my shelf unplugged, and life is much happier.
TOO FUNNY!  I can't stop laughing....
Oh my gosh, that was one of the funniest stories I've read in some time - you are brilliant.  :)

Thanks for the laughter.
I don't know about the clock - waking up stinks.  Period.  But the review is hysterical.  I loved it!
I agree with the person who commented that it takes more than a week to adjust to this clock. I have used this alarm clock for several months now and love it! I must rise early for work and was always so irritated to be jolted out of a sound sleep by the sound of my usual alarm. I still don't enjoy getting up early, but this is much nicer.
The best alarm clock I had was taking my vitamins everyday, going to bed at a reasonable hour everyday, taking half a caffine pill with an antihistamine and a controled otc nasal decongestant at least 30 mins before bed and waking up at the same time to the same loud alarm clock sound with an infinate snooze every 5 minutes set to a time way before I need to get up. This is the best method I've developed to tame the late sleeper I am.
Personally I am not in need of a 'nuclear alarm clock'. Julia, that is the funniest review I have ever read, and the tears of laughter are still wet on my cheek as I write this reply. Great job.
the review is quite funny!  I have a "Moonbeam" clock, which is an old Big Ben clock from 1950 that's been reintroduced. You can get it online and in a bunch of pretty colors from LLBean. What it does is flash a light at your designated time, and if that doesn't wake you, an alarm goes off five or so minutes later. I find waking up to a light much less jarring than an alarm. The only problem with it is that the clock itself has a constant brightly lit face, to the point that it's too bright for me to sleep. So I cover it with a denim napkin. Yes, kinda silly, but the flashing light still wakes me in the morning, and if I wake in the night I know to peer under the napkin to check the time. I wish they'd come out with a new version that allows you to adjust the brightness of the face, but I'm still happy with my Moonbeam, I've been using it for five years or more. And it's an adorable vintage design.
This is the most hilarious (and true) review I have ever read. I laughed so hard I had trouble breathing. I bought a similar alarm clock to this hoping for a calm, lovely morning awakening. Instead I slept through the alarm and when I woke up late, I was blinded. I saw white spots in my eyes for the next half hour. I packaged it back into its little box, drove to the shop & pretended like I hadn't used it. Refund!!
Wow... thank you. I needed that laugh. I'm a night person too and have yet to make it to my job on time. I'll never understand morning people... but of course, they're all zombies when we have to stay late and I'm bouncing off the walls :). Great product review.
I bet I'd sleep through this thing!!! Nothing short of a nuclear holocaust can wake me in the morning. I've tried just about every clock out there; I sleep through them all...I have literally even slept through a tornado less than 1000 feet from my house!!! I've always been and always will be a night owl, no matter how much light you shine in my face. When I was a teenager, I had a morning person for a best friend...she'd get up, turn the light on, jump on my bed, and start signing in a really annoying voice, and it still took her at least half an hour to get me out of bed. And it gets worse as I get older! I'm currently in my 20s...and I bet I'll be the next thing to a vegetable by the time I'm 50 yrs old! Either that or I'll only be up when the sun is not. I think my circadian rhythm is messed up...but then again, I think there's a lot more than that that's messed up with me.
I re-read this review sometimes when I need a good laugh, well done.  Incidently I too am a night person...being at work at 10am is hard for me, but being awake at 1am is sooo easy lol...


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):