ABOUT THIS BLOG

Does that new health or fitness product really do what it says it will? Let us find out for you. MSNBC.com writers and editors will periodically try out various products, devices and gadgets and report back their experiences. And experts will help us assess the evidence and spot quack claims. Have an item you'd like us to test? Send an e-mail to health@msnbc.com.



A shirt to make your skin softer?

Posted: Thursday, March 13, 2008 8:14 PM

By Anna Chan, contributing writer

What it is: Adea SeaCell Loungewear ($86-$154 on www.myadea.com)

Image:  SeaCell is a Lyocell fiber made with seaweed.
www.myadea.com

What it claims to do: Help promote skin renewal. The garments are made from a blend of cotton, elastane and a patented fiber from seaweed called SeaCell. The manufacturer says your body’s natural moisture will help release the vitamins (A and E) and minerals, as well as amino acids, from the seaweed. The garments also help wick sweat and neutralize odors because the fabric contains silver.

My experience: Dry, flaky skin is something I’ve battled with since childhood, so I was intrigued by the idea of clothes that claim to moisturize.. This SeaCell line is not easy on the wallet, so I ordered the cheapest item – the $86 basic tank top. For that much money, this shirt better work miracles on my skin, I thought. (The cost is equivalent to roughly eight bottles of the lotion that has done a good job of keeping my dryness at bay.)

The tank top arrived, adorned with a tag explaining that the fabric would “promote skin renewal” but didn’t have any instructions.  Do I wear the shirt as often as I would any other top? Should I hand wash it?  I poked around Adea’s Web site and couldn’t find anything to tell me there either.

So, with no instructions, I plunged in.

Since I had only one garment, I decided that wearing it to bed every night was probably the best way to give it a good test over a short period of time.

The first week, I slathered myself in lotion after my morning shower, like I usually do. And to test the garment’s claims of  wicking away sweat and neutralizing odors, I put flannel sheets on my bed, piled two thick blankets on top (much to my boyfriend’s chagrin) and even threw a hot water bottle under the covers for good measure. That should get my body’s natural moisture going while I sleep, I figured.

The result at the end of the first seven days? My skin felt the same, but my nights were less restful. My torso did feel sweat-free on those occasions that the high temps woke me mid slumber, and after several days, the shirt still didn’t smell. I even wore it to work out in at the end of the week. After half an hour on the elliptical, I didn’t feel sticky, but would it pass the sniff test? After failing to convince my boyfriend to take a deep whiff, I took the plunge myself. No smell!

The second week, after I washed the tank top, I decided to nix my usual lotion regimen. Not a good idea as it turned out.  By the end of the seven days, my torso had reverted back to the scaly, flaky dry skin I had years ago.

It seems that the shirt’s claim to “promote skin renewal” does not mean “help relieve dry skin.” I called Adea to get some clarification.

“Your skin breathes, so as you wear the product, your skin absorbs the vitamins and nutrients contained in the product. … So it hydrates skin and promotes renewal,” explained Christina Di Pierro, co-president of Adea. And be sure to keep using your lotion, she told me. “Used in conjunction with SeaCell, it definitely helps.”

And apparently, one has to wear the garment daily for two weeks to see results. “I’d say between 12 and 14 hours a day; maybe sleep in it,”  Di Pierro says.

As for the lack of instructions, the company hadn’t thought about the need for them until I called to express my confusion.  “We’ll start putting something in every package,” Di Pierro assured me.

What the experts say: Though seaweed is rich in vitamins and minerals, making it into clothing may not help your dry skin, says Dr. Julie Voss, a Seattle dermatologist. “The architecture of the skin is made to keep things out, especially if it’s not soluble, especially in a fiber,” she explained. “So you can have the nicest, most wonderful stuff, but it’s not getting to the blood supply of where the cells are.”

As for the product’s claims that it helps neutralize odors and wicks sweat, Voss doesn’t doubt it. “Silver kills the bacteria in odors,” she said.

Bottom line: The tank top was quite comfy, but seemed to do little for my skin during my albeit flawed trial period. But I can see these being a nice (though spendy) option for the gym.

Instead of shelling out $86 for a tank top, “If you want vitamin E, just put it in your lotion,” says Voss. “You don’t need a fancy shirt.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I'd like to know what lotion you use that works for you. I have a similar problem that has been an issue for me since childhood.
I am actually surprised they are using elastane (lycra) in their product. A vast majority of people with dry skin issues also have additional problems, such as excema. It has been my experience that elastane in fabrics actually exacerbates that problem; something the garments they peddle are meant to aid!

I won't be buying any, as I am one of the people that is sorely allergic to things like lycra and latex.
I have the same problem and I have been using CeraVe lotion for two months now and it works really well. My dermatoligist recommended it. It is 12 dollars a bottle though.
Spending that much money on anything but a formal shirt is laughable, anyway.

Lotions have always worked for me, I'll stick to them.
Another gimic to get people to spend a lot of money on a not so great product. When it comes to beauty, women try everything. Try commen sense, that works better, or Peoplespharmacy.com if you want simple solutions.
This stuff really works. It makes my teeth stronger and my dogs hair falls out more.
The tank seems likes a good work out shirt no laundry for a while, but at that price, I'll wash.
Nothing beats natural ingredients. Take a little "Unschlitt", mix it with Eau de Cologne and apply it. It smoothes the skin and further prevents a Sunburn if exposed to the sun
Peter
I have ezcema and I use Cetaphil, it is the only lotion that will keep me hydrated all day long, you can buy it at WalMart or Target.  It's a little pricy but well worth hydrated skin.  
the only thing that helps my Eczema is Aveeno Eczema Care. I used to have hives, horribly itchy, sometimes bigger then my whole hands all over my body, even on my head. My Sister-In-Law gave me this lotion from a friend whose daughter's doctor gave the kid a sample. I have been buying in bulk ever since. My skin is smooth, hive free and lovely! I rather spend the $20.00 for Bodywash + Lotion instead of $86 on a stupid shirt.
My mother has a fairly rare skin disease called Ickthiyosis (I hope I spelled that right?) and as I am getting a little older I have a very small case of it also. It is very hard to deal with and no amount of lotions or creams help. What does help? It's a miracle in a jar! Amlactin moisturizing lotion! You do not need a prescription and buy it from the pharmacy. It's $12.00 for 8 oz, and $20. for the larger bottle. I will buy the larger bottle next! I love it! My Husband has Eczema, he uses a prescription cream called Triamcinolone Cream. It has saved his life, he was in misery before he was prescribed this! To add to the benefits of either of these products you can also bathe for at 20 min's up to an hour in Dead Sea Salts's. I hope this helps someone else out there who has searched for relief!
To all of the Eczema sufferer's! I posted earlier about a prescription item called "Triamcinolone Cream", I think you should try this especially if you have insurance. Just paying your inurance co-pay should be cheaper than what you pay for the over the counter lotions and creams. See a Dermatologist and ask for this, I swear it will help and be cheaper for you in the long run!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):