ABOUT THIS BLOG

Does that new health or fitness product really do what it says it will? Let us find out for you. MSNBC.com writers and editors will periodically try out various products, devices and gadgets and report back their experiences. And experts will help us assess the evidence and spot quack claims. Have an item you'd like us to test? Send an e-mail to health@msnbc.com.



Reflexology mat walks line between 'om' and 'ouch'

Posted: Wednesday, December 17, 2008 9:12 PM

By Diane Mapes, contributing writer

 

What it is: Foot Chi  Cobblestone Foot Path ($49.90, includes shipping)

What it claims to do:  According to the manufacturer, the Foot Chi (pronounced “foot chee”) Cobblestone Foot Path is designed to emulate the “ancient stone reflexology pathways found throughout Asia” in order to “stimulate and regulate acupoints located on the soles of the feet.” Common benefits of reflexology, the literature states, are relaxation, improved circulation, and help with insomnia, sinusitis, allergies, fatigue, stress, anxiety and digestion.

Image: Foot Chi
footchi.com

My experience:  I decided to break out my Foot Chi on the day after Thanksgiving, when most of us are searching for something – anything! -- to help with that age-old holiday trifecta of stress, fatigue and digestive woes. Unfurling the bumpy strip of 16 x 57-inch green on my living room floor in front of the TV, I wondered if this qualified as the “peaceful space” the manufacturer suggested. Most likely not, but it did give me something to do while I paced back and forth across the cobbled surface.

As for that, unless you are accustomed to walking along riverbeds without shoes (or feel you’ve been very, very naughty and need punishing), do not try the Foot Chi barefoot. I did and lasted all of 30 seconds; it’s like walking around with lumps of coal in your shoes. After that, I gladly embraced the manufacturer’s suggestion that I wear socks if “lighter stimulation” was desired. One, two and finally three pairs seemed to do the trick for me (you may need less). Swathed in these protective layers of cotton, I was then able to trod upon what I came to call the Pebbled Path of Pain for the 5-10 minutes they advised for first-time users (the idea is work up to 10-40 minutes a week, although I could never get past 12-15).

None of which is to say that I did not like the whole Foot Chi experience. Perhaps it was just the relief of getting off the thing, but I definitely felt like I had a little more spring in my step after using it. In fact, I found it stimulating both for my feet – and my mind. The reflexology illustrations on the back of the box were especially entertaining. Who knew that the bottom tip of the little toe was directly linked to the frontal sinuses or that the area right in the middle of your heel stimulates the genital glands? Of course, this knowledge proved a bit discomfiting later on, when a few of my Foot Chi’s green plastic pebbles came off. Would I somehow be shortchanging my shoulder? Circumventing my spleen? Luckily, the Foot Chi folks had me covered. Their Web site offered tips on how to snap the pieces back into place should they fall off and extra stones are said to be included, although I couldn’t find mine. (This may have been due to a certain pre-holiday enthusiasm while opening the box as opposed to any kind of packing error.)

What the expert says: Dr. Howard Dinowitz, a Brooklyn podiatrist and spokesperson for New York State Podiatric Medical Association, says most of the evidence regarding the various benefits of reflexology is anecdotal rather than scientific. “Reflexology has been around for centuries and some people swear by it and some people swear at it,” he says. “Some say it’s cured their insomnia and their sciatica and that they breathe better and have wonderful erections because of it.”  A study conducted at the Oregon Research Institute does seem to offer more empirical proof, however. Researchers had 108 adults age 60 to 92 use a cobblestone mat for 16 consecutive weeks and found that it “improved physical function and reduced blood pressure to a greater extent than conventional walking in older adults.”

 

Dinowitz says he never “debates success,” but does advise moderation when using the Foot Chi, especially for people with diabetes who may suffer from neuropathy (i.e., the lack of peripheral sensation or feeling in the feet). “You might not feel if you’re bruising yourself or exacerbating an ulcer,” he says. “Otherwise, the only other people I would caution about using this product would be anybody with sensory nerve deprivation, anybody who has hypersensitive skin. And anybody who’s very ticklish.”

 

Bottom line: I primarily used my Foot Chi in the evening while watching TV, walking back and forth like the world’s loneliest picketer. Those looking for something less monotonous can purchase multiple paths in order to create some of the “new and exciting” arrangements touted on the Web site (otherwise known as a small rectangle, a large rectangle or a plus sign). Or they can just peel off a pair of socks for the full Princess and the Pea experience. Again, do not underestimate the power of hard plastic pebbles on the bottom of a soft, citified foot.

 

While I found walking back and forth on my Foot Chi a bit too stimulating at times and was annoyed by the number of pebbles that came off, I did enjoy using it while sitting at my computer, “walking” back and forth with only part of my weight as opposed to the full monty (the Web site also recommends using your Foot Chi at the spa, the park, the gym, the airport and the Ashram). This quick and easy DIY foot massage definitely put me on the path to true happiness – and kept me alert even during those post-lunch afternoon lulls. I don’t know that it did all that much for my sinuses or my circulation, but I haven’t had any bouts of insomnia since I started using it (quite the feat during the holiday season).  This may just be the perfect thing – for those who’ve been naughty and nice.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

"Who knew that the bottom tip of the little toe was directly linked to the frontal sinuses or that the area right in the middle of your heel stimulates the genital glands?"

No one!  Because they're not!

Reflexology loves to tout this "connected to," but proponents can never quite explain what that means.  Are they saying specific nerves connect them? No. Specific blood vessels, then?  Of course not.  What, then?

There is no reason to think specific parts of the foot have direct influence over specific parts of the body.  Nor is there any evidence to back up that claim.

People perceive benefits from Reflexology because... brace yourself... foot rubs feel really really good.
Reflexology works wonders, I get a Foot Massage with in hours of landing in Sanghai, I make a point to get the massage every other day while Traveling in China, This service is not available anywhere in the USA.

I don't know the cobblestone path, but after 1hr od the foot massage my whole body feels relaxed, this is better than the full body massages here in the USA.

Reflexology if applied right works wonders, there is no control when walking on this path of stones I think, with good areas bad areas are also getting pressed which can cause discomfort and more pain than you initially had.

You can't please everybody.
I have one & walk on it every morning while I'm brushing my teeth!  Yes, I'm a multi-tasker.   My Sonicare brush has a timer so I get at least 2 minutes a day then any time I can fit in after that.  I find it revitalizing and a good way to start a day.  
No, I haven't tried it, but I believe the PLACEBO effect would apply here.
I grew up in a trailer park (feel free to laugh) where I was surrounded by gravel my entire childhood. Children love to go barefoot. So, I spent my first 18 years on this planet walking barefoot on gravel. I must say, I had no noticeable benefits. But then again, I didn't pay good money for the experience and then LOOK for benefits, either. All I'm saying is, find some gravel and walk on it before you order this piece of junk. You may just decide to donate the money to the poor instead.
Ah as science progresses I find they "discover" more and more the great miracles of the natural world that esoterists and ancient civilizations practiced for millenia. One day, maybe they'll discover that what they rejected on the day they commenced towards material scientific discoveries is the very thing they seek to uncover.
THE EXPERIENCE ON THIS CONVERTED SURF BOARD WOULD BE
TO MUCH FOR ME - I HAVE DIABETES AND MY FEET ARE VERY
SENSITIVE TO PAIN - SEEMS ALITTLE ROUGH AND COULD CAUSE INJURY - I"LL PASS ON THIS ONE ---
I live in Japan and the local park has a 50ft circular "massage" path.  I have tried it a few times, and while it definitely hurts, I feel fantastic afterwards.  The "foot-chi" stone pattern seems to be a copy of the foot "massage" paths I see here.  

Anyhow, its natural and feels good.  Win-Win situation!
I would suspect that the device does as well as the "Ionized Bracelet" sold for high prices on TV.  (Scientifically speaking, there is no such thing as an Ionized metal at room temperature).  

If you want to waste your money and are easily persuaded that things like this foot massager or Ionized Bracelets actually work, pay your money and enjoy.  
Chalk up another one for the placebo effect!
TJ from CA:

"Ah as science progresses I find they "discover" more and more the great miracles of the natural world that esoterists and ancient civilizations practiced for millenia."

An example, pray tell?  

With all due respect, "science" hardly ever buys off on such things as millenium old cures.  Once they're tested to see if they actually do what proponents say they do, they perform no better than placebo.  Which means that they don't work.

Now, marketers and CAM peddlers buy off on the "ancient cure" thing, and will tell you such things work, but don't confuse what they do with actual research.

(and FYI, Reflexology is hardly an example of ancient.  It was invented by an American in the late 1930s)
More research is needed regarding the benefits of Reflexology.
I have been trying something similar to this, it's a device with cilinders with these sharp ends to walk on. I found it very stimulating and it certainly helped me with the circulatory problems of my legs.
You can also buy a simplified board in any specialty shop or online.  I got mine for about $15 while I was in school for Reflexology.  

If it's too tender you can always place a towel over it to cushion it a little.  

Not every modality is for everyone but Reflexology has been around for a lot longer than the 30's.  
Artwork was found in an 6th century Egyptian tomb and European doctors in the 1500's wrote about 'pressure' and zone therapy.  (Just a couple of examples)  

It might work for you, I'd rather go to park that has a foot path!  Too bad there's none nearby.
For the last 26 years I have been using Reflexology for treating varios human ailmants.I have achieved great success in treating diseases relating to every system of  human body. I can very emphatically say that Reflexology is a greatest gift God has given to man to live healthy.
This concept might work, but I prefer the good old fashion accupressure points and I KNOW THEY WORK!!
I use them daily and have great results.. including my feet and all the points on them.
Can you say Endorphins?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):