ABOUT THIS BLOG

Does that new health or fitness product really do what it says it will? Let us find out for you. MSNBC.com writers and editors will periodically try out various products, devices and gadgets and report back their experiences. And experts will help us assess the evidence and spot quack claims. Have an item you'd like us to test? Send an e-mail to health@msnbc.com.



Zip! 5-Hour Energy packs a punch

Posted: Thursday, February 12, 2009 7:15 PM

By Melissa Dahl, health editor

What it is: 5-Hour Energy, a teeny, 2-fl. oz. drink priced at about $3.99.

Image: 5-Hour Energy
5hourenergy.com

What it claims to do:  Boost your energy for five hours – without the caffeine crash later.

My experience: I’ve recently discovered that I am becoming old. Not physically old, mind you; I’m still several weeks shy of my 24th birthday. No, the other, lamer kind of old – the kind who secretly wants to be asleep by 11 on a Friday night. The younger of the voices in my head, however, rarely allows this, and constantly berates me to act my age. And so began my quest to find an energy drink that I can stomach – and one that actually works.

Coffee makes me jittery, and most energy drinks taste horrible; plus, many of them have tons of sugar and upwards of 200 calories. That’s what initially drew me to the 5-Hour Energy drink: It has only four calories and no sugar. I was skeptical that a drink this little could actually do what it claims, but I tried it on a Friday night, at dinner with a friend.

It definitely has that strange chemical-y taste that all energy drinks share, but at only 2 ounces, it’s all over in just a couple of sips. (The lemon-lime flavor, in my opinion, is the least offensive. Avoid mixed berry at all costs – it’s reminiscent of cough syrup.) And before I really even realized it, I was peppier and in the mood to stay out and have some fun. My friend went home after dinner, and normally, I’d have been tempted to do the same – but instead, I headed to a friend’s birthday festivities (and had a lovely, alert time).

The next morning, my boyfriend had agreed to help me move into my new apartment, and when I woke up, I tried another one of these little energy drinks – and then had the motivation to move two carloads full of my stuff over to my new place by myself! When he finally dragged himself out of bed and over to my place at 11, loading up what was left of my stuff into his truck only took 15 minutes.

This elixir has a gradual way of working to boost your energy, and in the same way that it slowly perks you up,  it gently lowers you back down a few hours later. I tried it again a several times in the morning before work, and I never got any jitters – and they’re not kidding about the lack of a crash later.

I knew it worked to boost my energy, but still, the science-experiment taste worried me – what’s in this stuff?

What the expert says: New York City dietitian Bonnie Dix-Taub sounded a little miffed when I told her of the wonders of the 5-Hour Energy drink and how well it seemed to work for me. It may make you peppier, she said, “but what is the price you’re paying for the possibility of energy?”

She helped me unpack the mysteries of the 5-Hour Energy drink’s ingredients. It contains about as much caffeine as a cup of coffee, but a closer look at some of the other ingredients listed on the drink's nutrition facts is pretty astounding:

  • Niacin: 30 milligrams, or 150 percent of the recommended daily value
  • Vitamin B6: 40 milligrams, or 2,000 percent daily value
  • Vitamin B12: 500 micrograms (0.5 milligrams), or 8,333 percent daily value

But what does it all mean? “Just because a little of something is good doesn’t mean a lot is better,” Taub-Dix says. So all of these nutrients (all B vitamins) are necessary, but the excessive amounts are not – and too much of some nutrients can even be dangerous, she says.

Niacin helps the digestive system, nerves and skin to function properly, and the recommended daily amount for adults is 14 milligrams a day; a bottle of 5-Hour Energy has twice that. Too much niacin can cause your face to flush and feel itchy, which can last for 15 to 30 minutes. (To be fair, the back of the bottle notes the possibility of a niacin flush.)

“It’s not that likely that you’re going to get an overdose of B12,” Taub-Dix says, but too much B6 (more than 200 milligrams – or about five bottles of 5-Hour Energy) can cause nerve toxicity, which messes with your muscle coordination and can make you seriously clumsy, or even paralyzed. The label warns consumers not to drink more than two bottles a day.

It’s more healthful to get your daily dose of these vitamins in foods like fish or dairy products, Taub-Dix says, who lists three rules for natural energy: Get enough sleep, exercise regularly and eat well.

Bottom line: Heeding the advice of nutritionists, I’ll try to only drink these 5-Hour Energy drinks occasionally. But I really like the gentle way these drinks boost your energy and then bring you back down; I’ll definitely turn to them again when I want a little extra energy.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I have used the 5 Hour and like the Orange and Berry flavor the best.  With diabetis and high blood pressure I have I find it does help me focus and consentrate better after only about a minute. I can get them off eBay for much cheaper than if I get them in the store even with shipping. I only use 1 when I need one.
I agree with you.  This product really works.  I have one in the morning but only if I need one.  This product really works and I now buy them at Costco in bulk so I have them at work and at home.  I even like all the flavors I have tried.  I have had Lemon/Lime, Citrus and berry.  I did try their 6-hour version and had the flushing that niacin can do.  But I have never had that problem with the 5-hour version.
I LOVE these litte drinks. I dont drink them often, but maybe a couple times a month but the DO work and there is NO crash.  
Pour the lemon lime into a glass of soda (I use Sprite Zero) and you'll barely taste it.  :)
My experience with the effects of the 5-Hour Energy drinks parallel what is described here. I was thrilled when I discovered the product at a truck stop on a long road trip a few years back, and was amazed at well it works. I've since used it for kick-starting me prior to my weight training sessions, as it helps both focus and energy, as well as for those late afternoon slumps sitting through interminable meetings at the office. I only wish I could find a distributor that allowed bulk purchase pricing!
I absolutely love these drinks. But I agree that they should be used in moderation.

I've found that drinking one every morning for a couple of weeks will lower the drink's effectiveness. I think the body gets used to 8000% of its B12 requirements, which may not be a good thing. So not only is it healthier to drink it occasionally, it also makes sure the product stays effective for you.
That all sounds pretty good to me.  Ok, so if you guzzle 5 of them at once, there contains enough niacin to potentially cause nerve toxicity - but hell, if you do 5 shots of tequila at once, you're likely to fall over drunk.  So yeah, even good stuff in large enough quantities are no good.  Sure seems a whole lot better than any of the alternatives out there.
It works as stated. Imagine that...a label that is acutally truthful and not hype. I use it periodically.  I have tried various energy drinks and they make me jittery. This one does not.
I LOVE goin' "On the Five".  I agree that it should be used in moderation, but when I need a kick, it works.  I usually take it before a concert or night out.  Makes me feel like a rock star, minus the cocaine.
Try XS energy drinks - available in a multitude of flavors including cranberry-grape, citrus, cola, lemon-lime, tropical,peach tea and green tea etc etc  as well as caffeine free flavors. Available online through Amway Global. In addition to B12 and B6 also has herbs such as ginseng, gingko biloba and others with as much caffeine as a 8oz cup of coffee. Gives a healthful lift of energy with no crash at all as there's no sugar, no carbs. Also avilable in Australia and England where some energy drinks have been banned
Wow, only 24 and already needing energy drinks.  I'm 40 and work 12 hrs a day for 14 days straight.  I drink a little coffee during the day, but find no need for other energy boosters.  Perhaps you're not really looking at the root cause of your lack of energy.  
Placebo
I have to disagree with you on the flavors as I HATE the nasty Lemon-Lime,  but tolerate Orange!  I don't know why it works, I just know it does work for me.  It's more of a 2 - 3 hour energy boost for me but when I'm hitting the wall in the afternoon -- it saves me from ending up face first in keyboard at my desk!
Of course the medical experts and pharmaceutical groups don't like this stuff.....can't patent it and make any money!!
There are better ways to increase your energy vis supplementation. Biologically you want to increase Adenosine Triphospate (ATP). After 17 years in nutrition and over $100 million in sales to tens of thousands of consumers I have learned a thing or two about what works best for most people (people continue to purchase what delivers results). The best I have ever found are the adaptogens Schizandra, Rhodiola, Eluthero, & Cordyceps. Research on scholar.google.com will yield over 43,000 citations in the literature and when you consider these botanical extracts have been used in some cases for thousands of years safely, well, why not try them.

I was a 30 year, 1,000mg per day caffeine user prior to switching to the adaptogens. One catch, you must consume clinically efficacious levels of each one, but still it tips the scales at about a third of what the 5-hour energy will set you back and actual blood tests have proven over and over again the actual increase in ATP in your body. More "energy" No crash, no side effects.

Have a groovy day
tommyj
FRS (Lance Armstrong) has an energy program that seems to work, too.  The problem I found with that was their web-site offers a 2 week trial supply but doesn't tell you you are signing up for an automatic re-supply ($70 per month).  You can find this at the end of a 6 page contract you agree to by ordering the free trial.  The contract is found by clicking a obscure link on the web-site.  This turned me off and expended all the energy in frustration.  I trusted Lance Armstrong!
If you are looking for lasting energy, try the world's first Multivitamin with sales of $3Billion.
https://broaden.mychoices.biz/Retail/Products.aspx?PG=3

And an energy drink brand named XS with 9 flavors and all less than 16 calories
there is even a better energy tonic out there called xtra sharp. It does not contain sugar, caffeine, sodium or high doses of B vitamins. It is made from a proprietary blend of herbs and minerals. Drink only 30oz and enjoy 24 hours of energy boost. With xtrasharp, you don't stop till you quit.
Most energy drinks, pills, etc., make me very jittery, but 5 Hour Energy Drinks?  They work.  I was driving back and forth across Michigan in one day, and they were my savior.  They're not for every day...but I admit, I always have one around for emergencies.
This stuff is great for road trips.  We drove to Hilton Head from Columbus, OH, I took about a 4 hour nap before we headed out at 4am.  The last thing I wanted to do when I woke up was get in a car for 12-13 hours, but I drank one about a half an hour before we left and by the time we hit the freeway I was wide awake.  While everyone else slept I was wide awake singing just about every song that came on the radio.  I try not to do energy drinks very often, but this is always my first choice when I need a pick me up.
thanks - I have contemplated trying this before and based on your article, I feel sufficiently warned and informed to give it a try.
I am a bicycle commuter and hard rider. I have been using them for a couple of years on really long bicycle rides,  100 milers or longer and I love the way they pick me up and keep me going strong,  full of energy.
I'm a road warrior service tech. I discovered, at 48 years old, that sometimes I can use a little extra oomph to get though a long day. (the previous sentence is actually a huge under-statement)Sometimes I can actually FEEL my tail dragging! Anyway, I tried one of these energy shots, available at most fine gas station convenience stores. These things are great! I now keep one in my back pack for emergencies. I don't use them every day. But it's nice to have one when it seems impossible, otherwise, to make it through the rest of the day in a meaningful way.
I use them all the time and find to be very effective, and never experience any jitters. I by them by the six pack but never taske more then one a day.  They have gotten me through some very diffucult times.
The daily recommended amount for adults by the experts
is for a healthy 18-20 year old adult. Not the average Joe who has deficiencies in just about every
needed vitamin. 5 glasses of milk give you the
recommended daily amount of calcium. If I drink 7 glasses everyday will I "OD" on calcium? So I think in moderation these drinks are fine. I use them quite
often as a 46 year old male who wants to have energy
to make it through tough days after long nights.
When I was in Hawaii I used these drinks to help me keep my energy when I was surfing... it made for longer days on the ocean and I had better pickup when I was catching the waves
I like these little power packed drinks.  because I want to make sure that I don't get the jitters (and because I don't like the taste) I have always drank about half a bottle and put the rest into a citrus type soda.  Other times I put the whole thing into a soda.
My experience with 5 Hour was much the same. It made me more alert without the crash later and allowed me to sleep when I needed to. I head the max 2 doses a day - too much of a good thing is not good.
For a while I was addicted to energy drinks. Had to have them just to get going. I think I became so used to them,that they seemed to stop working. Must have spent a small fortune on them, $20 a week. Don't do them that much anymore, they cost way to much.
You should try Revive Energy Mints.  Each mint has the energy of an energy drink, but they are sugar free, PLUS have the Top 3 Superfoods (acai berry, mangosteen and goji berry).  You don't get that 'crash' like you get with most energy drinks! Check them out here:  www.revive-energymints.com  
Funny, the B6 "nerve toxicity" sounds a lot like being drunk...
I find nutritionists to be a bit impractical.  No one is going to say that drinking 5 of these things in a day would be good.  I think that of the choices these are the best of of the alternatives, last time I tried to get a little pep in my step by eating a ridiculous amount of fish, my girlfriend wouldn't talk to me for a week.
I was skeptical about 5 hour energy also and decided to try it on one of my trips back home.  Driving 13 hours over 2 days can be very tiring even if you are sitting down all the time.  Surprisingly I found that it did keep me awake and alert, and didn't have the crash like drinking 3-4 Dr. Peppers, 2-3 candy bars or bags of M&M's normally cause.  I've actually recommended it to other people since I never had any problems with it and it did just like it advertised.  Knowing about the risks of having too much is nice to know, but it does say not to have more then 3-4 of them in a 24 hour period on the label, and if you need 5 of these to get thru the day, you definately need a vacation.
Wow. Does 5-hour Energy advertise with MSNBC? Is this really newsworthy? What's next? Articles on the health benefits of Ecstacy? Perhaps a "Cocaine Makes Sex Fun" plug? "Alcoh9l Isn't Just Recreational Anymore"?

America. What a great place. A substance for every mood.
How much did the manufacturer pay you to write this "objective" article?
CAUTION IF YOU HAVE A HISTORY OF RENAL PROBLEMS. A FAMILY MEMBER HAD TAKEN AS DIRECTED AND ENDED UP WITH BILATERAL FLANK PAIN, VERY HIGH POTASSIUM LEVEL AND INCREASE BUN/CREATININE, ALL SIGNS OF INJURY TO THE KIDNEYS. ALTHOUGH I HAVE TRIED THEM AND THEY WORK VERY WELL AS DESCRIBED IN YOUR ARTICLE.
There may be risks involved, but it sounds a lot safer than gulping down Red Bull!
the advertisments for this product are everywhere.  i rather liked reading an article on it and if it actually works.  
I've recently tried a brand new energy drink called Blu Frog which is actually very healthy. It has a product called Limu in it and i'm addicted.
its brand new and its awesome it has some natural caffeine from guarana seed extract and B12 and B6. If you drink energy drinks you must try it! blufrogenergy.com/post
I would never recommend any of the energy drinks I've tried in the past. Some made my heart race to seemingly dangerous levels. After having a particularly busy week with little sleep I decided to try 5 Hour. This is absolutely the first product that I've tried that works as described on the packaging. The niacin flush last for a few seconds if at all. There are some knockoff brands available at a third to half the cost. They seem to work comparatively well also.
I am 58 years of age and I play in an over-50 basketball league. I use 5 Hour Energy before each session and  have found that it really works. I agree that moderation is important.
I have to say, that I tried this product once several months ago for that "pick me up" I needed that morning, due to not having my coffee that day.  I honestly did not feel a thing!  Maybe I stayed up too late the night before and it did help some and I just didn't realize it.  Maybe if I had enough sleep the night before, I would have felt the boost, but that one time I tried it, I felt nothing.  I think I will give it another try soon though, just to give it a second chance.
I tried one of these the other day to see how well they work. Ater waiting 2 hours for it to kick in, I gave up and took a nap. It didn't do anything for me.
I've found that these drinks are a nice pic me up when I'm tired and I know I need to stay up a late to finish a grant project. I estimate how long I need to stay up and plan accordingly. It works for me.
I have been hesitant to try this stuff.  After reading your article I feel more informed.  I will defintely give it a try the next time I see it in the store.  Thanks.
I guess I'll put my 2 cents in here as far as endorcing companies with their best energy drinks. The first and only healty & nutritious energy drink (3 years running) goes to drinkACT.com. That is the company website, not mine. If you really looked into what's in your typical energy drinks, be it cans, candy or shots. You would be looking for a safer alternative. drinkACT knew this 3 years ago, that when after the public caught wind of what these so called energy drinks are doing to them, they would be turning to a better way of getting energy in a safer way. Healthy energy drinks are the next trend because people want what's good for them.
Tried it a coupkle of times.  It didn't do squat.
Welcome to the world of performance enhancement!  They may not be called "drugs," but they do what all performance enhancing products do -- whether it is coffee, an energy bar, aspirin, antibiotics or steroids -- they alter the body's chemistry to achieve a result the body is not otherwise capable of producing.  What makes this product any different than many of the products athletes use to compete better?  Is it safer?  Even vitamins taken in excess can cause significant problems, as discussed above.  Before you start attacking athletes for using performance enhancing products, think about the supercharged cup of coffee you had this morning to help you start the day and to help you accomplish your job (if you are lucky enough to be working!).  
My wife and I generally split one and find that that having just 2.5 hours worth is plenty for an evening out.
Look at all the 5 hour haters, its great sorry your drinks wont be getting my money
Is there something wrong with me?  I heard all of this good stuff about the 5Hr and it made my stomach feel sick and didn't do anything for my energy level....Hmmmm.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):