ABOUT THIS BLOG

Does that new health or fitness product really do what it says it will? Let us find out for you. MSNBC.com writers and editors will periodically try out various products, devices and gadgets and report back their experiences. And experts will help us assess the evidence and spot quack claims. Have an item you'd like us to test? Send an e-mail to health@msnbc.com.



Tired tootsies? YogaToes ease foot pain

Posted: Wednesday, May 27, 2009 1:21 PM

By Helen A.S. Popkin, tech editor

What it is: YogaToes by YogaPro, $49.95 plus shipping

What it claims to do: According to the manufacturer's Web site, YogaToes do the following:

  • Exercise your feet to stay healthy & in shape.
  • Improve and prevent foot problems by stretching & aligning your toes.
  • Ease the discomfort of hammertoes, bunions & plantar fasciitis.
  • Recover from stress, strain and overuse. Improve foot strength, flexibility and appearance.
  • Increase circulation, straighten bent toes, and realign joints.
  • Improve and reduce the aches and pains associated with poor posture.

My experience: “Make sure that you are getting the authentic YogaToes,” warns the YogaPro Web site. “Beware of imitations.” And indeed there are imitators; Pampered Toes ($9.99) and Healthytoes ($34.99) to name two. You get what you pay for, seems to be the implication. Upon casual inspection however, YogaToes and its imitators seem at least superficially the same.

Image: YogaToes
yogapro.com

No matter, for this review I’m trying out the $49.95 name brand – my poor tired tootsies deserve the alleged-best. They’ve had a tough time of it the past decade or so. My feet, once blessed with a symmetrical loveliness, now suffer the lumpy indignities of congenital flat-footedness. (Thanks, Mom!)

The $400 medical orthotics (that insurance doesn’t cover) did nothing to prevent – yeech – bunions. These hideous lumps cause my big toes to push inward, crowding the space of the second toes and leaving my dogs barking at the end of every day – even though I wear pretty sensible shoes.

So, when I first happened upon an advertisement for YogaToes, I was instantly drawn to the product that claimed it could align my unruly big toes. When my YogaToes arrived in the mail, I ripped open the package to find a surprisingly gelatinous set of  tootsie grates resembling the toe separators used for pedicures, only much larger and fully enclosed. Overall, the YogaToes didn’t much resemble the sparkling “sapphire blue” product on the Web site, nor were they as firm as they appeared.

The YogaToes came with only the most basic of instructions. It’s advised to wet the YogaToes so you can more easily place each toe in its individual slot and wear for 10 minutes a day at first so your muscles can get used to stretching. I found it fairly easy to put the YogaToes on my feet without wetting them first, and they were quite comfortable. I observed the 10 minute limit at first, somewhat worried about charley horses. However, throughout my first two weeks with YogaToes, I suffered no discomfort during and after use.

As the first week progressed, I began to use the YogaToes up to an hour or so at a time while watching television because I found them so comfortable.  Removing the YogaToes is simple, even if they aren’t pre-moistened. After each use, my toes felt nicely separated for at least an hour – a happy change from the achy bunched feet that come out of my shoes each evening when I come home from work. I’ve tried warming YogaToes with hot water, and chilling them in the refrigerator, as suggested by the manufacturer – both ways were tolerable. However, I prefer YogaToes at room temperature.

What the expert says: “I really like YogaToes,” Dr. Carol Frey told me. Seeing as Dr. Frey is assistant clinical professor of orthopedic surgery at UCLA, as well as co-director and West Coast Sports Medicine Foundation director of orthopedic foot and ankle surgery in Manhattan Beach, Calif., I figure she knows what she’s talking about.

Still, Frey didn’t learn about YogaToes at some high falutin’ foot doctor convention, but from her patients. YogaToes are perfect for the foot-strengthening exercises Frey prescribes for her patients –  much better than the pedicure toe separators she had been using. “And you can use them hot or cold,” added Dr. Frey, who has used chilled YogaToes on post-operative patients.

Fray says YogaToes are helpful in preventing or relieving mild corns or bunion pain, especially for those who wear tight shoes or high heels which squeeze the feet into unnatural positions. YogaToes would not be helpful for those suffering from moderate to severe foot pain or deformities, she added.

And what about those cheap YogaToes knockoffs? “It’s a very simple, straight-forward design, so even the knockoffs get it right, as long as they stretch the toes just enough without being painful.”

Bottom line: After several weeks of use, my feet still have their various flat-footed issues, and my bunions still ache at the end of the day – not that I expected them to be “cured.” However, the YogaToes did and do leave my feet feeling relaxed after use, and I look forward to using them at the end of each day. Still, I can’t reconcile the nearly $50 price tag for a pair of rubber grates that undoubtedly cost a fraction of that amount to produce. Now that I have them, however, I will continue to use them on a regular basis.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I might be totally clueless here; but couldn't one just place cotton balls between the toes and get about the same results?  Or any similarly inexpensive items, such as bunched facial tissues?
Since bunions cannot be cured except by removing the bone-up on the bone (which is what that bulge is), how is this company allowed to blatantly lie about their product's capability?  While the product sounds comfortable and somewhat therapeutic, I would absolutely not purchase this overpriced version from a company that fraudulently claims it can cure a condition that it obviously cannot.
Isembard - in all fairness, the writer says that the company claims to "ease the discomfort" - they don't say they will cure bunions.  But, as Hap Pupe says, there are probably other, less expensive, ways to achieve the same relief.  Not something I would spend $50 on for sure!
I have Yoga Toes and suffer the same fate as mentioned in the article. They do work, but with daily use. It has stopped my foot from further movement and does make my foot feel exercised and relaxed. I do wear both, though only one foot is affected. I would recommend them highly. The price is a little steep, but they do have a life time warranty should they fail beyond normal wear and tear.
Yes, you do get what you pay for...i have actually tried some of the products in question. Pampered Toes are supposed to be one size fits all--not true. On top of that you cant even return them if they dont fit. I ended up calling the people at Yogatoes and not only do they have custom sizes but they helped me understand how to use the product. i only wish i hadnt wasted my time/money on junk.Yogatoes are the only thing that worked for me.
There are several magazines that have YogaToes advertisements in the back (Us Weekly for sure). These ads have a code to receive a discount on the product. Also, the more pairs you purchase, the larger the discount.

I purchased two pairs (one for me, one to give away), and have both really enjoyed the product.
I received a set of YogaToes from a friend of mine who said she was tired of listening to me complain about my sore feet and worrying about my toes getting bet around in weird angles as I got older.  I totally love them and use them daily - after a bath or shower they make me feel as though I've had a foot massage.  I'm a dude and on my feet in workboots 10 - 12 hours a day.  
I have some serious hammer toe and would love something that would help.  The problem is that these are one size fits all.  I wear a size six in women's shoes.  I've tried the full-size ones, but by the time I get to my pinky toe it has to go almost horizontal to fit in the alotted spot.
I've been using a Yoga Toes knock-off from Wal-Mart since I developed a bunion on my right foot.  I love them!  I don't think they realign joints or straighten bent toes, but they certainly relieve discomfort and are a treat at the end of a day when my poor feet have been jammed into heels all day.  
Sorry, but Yoga Toes is the biggest rip off ever. It doesn't ease pain whatsoever, nor fix feet problems that it claims to fix and plus it's horrendously expensive! I am really surprised that this is run on the front page of cnn.com.
I practice yoga a lot and this simple ritual relieves tension in tired feet! I massage the bottoms of my feet and toes with a plain ol tennis ball and it works wonders...stand or sit down with the ball under your foot and use your body weight to push down on the ball, rolling back and forth...you will quickly notice any tender spots that need attention, like the arch.
$50? Really? The toe separators that they use for pedicures will do exactly the same thing for $49.70 fewer dollars. I don't know about you but I can think of many other ways to spend $50.
I use my Yogatoes regularly and they do relax my feet and relieve some of the pain from my bunion.  They are pricey, but I expect they will last forever.
Yogatoes blow.  Plain and simple.  They are a cheap product that don't cost more than a dollar or two to make so the other $47.95 is filler with the idea that expensive products mean quality, which it doesn't.
For the people that bought yogatoes over any of the cheaper options.. I have a bridge in Brooklyn I will sell you too.
I'm sorry Emily, but I think you might be wrong in your statement. Obviously YogaToes DOES work if it has as many people claiming so as it does.

I personally have back problems that are causing foot problems. At only 22 I am having to consider orthodics. I would personally rather give something like YogaToes a shot and relieving the pain, than paying as much as I would for the alternative!

I'm ordering. :-)
I've had bunions all my life (juvenile bunions) and I recently had them surgically corrected.  I am using my Yoga Toes to exercise my toes during the physical therapy I'm going through now to return flexibility to my feet.  They are a great help and I feel rest assured that my $50 was well-spent because of their lifetime warranty.
Yogatoes work VERy well for me.
I have the $10 Pampered Toes, and love them!!!  No reason to spend the extra $40, I don't think....
Kali,

Orthodics?....err orthopedics?
I have YogaToes and I love them.  They don't really "solve" any foot issues but they really do stretch my toes out after wearing heals all day.  It feels great, just like a good stretch to any part of the body does after a long day of work.  I bought mine at CVS and certainly did not pay $50.00 for them.  I probably wouldn't have tried it if it had cost that much.
thanks to Katie for suggesting to check magazines for discounts for yoga toes.  i subscribe to body and soul magazine - and in the april issue was a $15 coupon for the yoga toes (I noticed that not all issues had the coupon - so you may want to look through your back issues).  thanks for saving me some money!
Have you ever tried Fit Flops?  They are the best shoe I have ever worn. I have had heel problems for over a year, plantar fasciitis etc. and w/in a few days of wearing my feet feel great...even better than with my $400 orthotics.  they cost about the same as the YogaToes.
I've had foot problems for years. I had bilateral bunion surgery years ago which solved many of them ... but still a long day makes for sore feet.
I got the "knock off" Pampered Toes about six months ago. I generally use them every night and they ARE helpful. I wear a size 10 and they fit fine.
Do they SOLVE problems. Well, my mild hammer toes are marginally less pronounced. But, more importantly they do help my feet feel better after a long day and what more can you ask out of $10???
Ive seen the knockoffs out at WalMart and have wondered if they helped or not. For 9.95 its worth a try since i stand on my feet all day at work in steel toe boots.
Hap Pupe,

You can definitely use less expensive items to promote the same relief! I work at a massage clinic and small stones are usually used to place between the toes during a Hot Stone Massage. I suppose it's just about being creative...
I have Yoga toes, you can get them for $10 at Bed, Bath and Beyond. They are definitely worth it! I feel relief everytime I take them off. I usually take a shower and slide them on after cramming my toes in "cute" shoes all day.
I'm sorry, its pampered toes that I like. I don't have an opinion on yoga toes other than that seems expensive.
I have the knock offs. I dont expect them to fix any problems but I like the feeling that comes with use. My feet feel great (wearing them and after) andI like to use them while watching TV. I think they're great!
Currently I am using a similar product bought at Walmart.  They make my feet feel soooooo good afterwards.  They are a little difficult to put on especially around my little toe.  I was wondering if the Yogatoes are easer to put on.  I think $ 50 is a bargain.  The walmart brand is made of stiff foam, I would think the gel is much nicer on the feet.
My yoga person recommended SmartToes www.smarttoes.com toe stretchers. They're more comfortable and less expensive than Yoga Toes. They're also easier to put on. She gave me the code MB10 for 10% off and I love them!
I have tried yaga toes and I have tried yoga sandals,  I now have 5 pair of youga sandals that have the same principal only they are a sandal.  They work great for mortons neuroma which I have in both feet. I wear them all day and they feel great.
I love these so much. My feet feel like any part of your body feels after a good stretch! I bought the knock offs at amazon and think they are a great deal and a great product. I would not have paid 50 bucks...
I use Yoga toes for plantar fasciitis,restless leg syndrome and  periodic limb movement disorder. They have been very useful in successfully reducing foot and leg pains that cause severe sleep fragmentation. I purchased the "brand name" because knock offs are usually close but not the same. Try on a pair of Crocs after trying on a pair of knock offs and you'll see what I mean.
I'm on my feet all day as well.. I didn't spend 50 or 10 bucks on mine. I got a pair of them for like 6 bucks at target!! I assume their working just as well as the named brand 'yoga toes'!!!  try em!!!:)
Another very happy Yoga Toes customer here! My feet had a number of problems, including partially-collapsed arches, a neuroma, and scrunched-over (hammer) toes, all of which caused near-constant pain. I felt something happening almost immediately, and I could see changes after two weeks. It took a year, but to my amazement my toes lie completely flat and straight now, and my arches are restored. More importantly, I'm pain-free.

For those (including Helen) who are not getting any real effect from your Yoga Toes, you may need the larger size. Yogapro recommends the small for most women, but thanks to posts on an exercise forum, I learned that the larger size is often more appropriate, unless you have teeny feet or tiny toes. (Yogapro will exchange sizes at no cost.)

BTW, $15-off discount codes are always available; google will find them for you.
I have Healthy Toes and they have done absolute wonders for my toes!!  I also tried Yoga Toes which were much more difficult to put on and seemed like the gel was harder.  I will never give up my Healthy Toes!!
I have just bought my pair of yoga toes and with some of the negative comments above i'm wondering if i did the right thing. probably small is not the right size for me as the end to my great toes are left open. I will explore the size return option mentioned by Lynn if this doesn't work.  i've just started 2 days now so i'm watching what the effects will be. they are very tight and become somewhat uncomfortable if i keep them on for two long - but maybe that's the initial feel, so i'll assess it for a while
I'm always on the look out for stuff that I can use to pamper my feet. After searching online, I found and purchased the HealthyToes toe stretcher - they're awesome!! I found them at a great price at http://www.activeforever.com/p-5186-healthy-toes-toe-stretchers.aspx?intcmp=search

It helps relieve sore feet and toes in just minutes and feels so good after wearing heels all day- I even purchased them for my mom, who's a Nurse and on her feet all day. Highly recommended!
Dan S.
Next time you try to correct someone, please check your facts first.  Orthopedics is a specialized area of medicine.  Orthotics are orthopedic devices designed "to support, align, prevent, or correct deformities or to improve the function of movable parts of the body".
Molly,
I'm glad that someone corrected Dan S.  Especially since he was being so smug about his fact correcting.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):