ABOUT THIS BLOG

Does that new health or fitness product really do what it says it will? Let us find out for you. MSNBC.com writers and editors will periodically try out various products, devices and gadgets and report back their experiences. And experts will help us assess the evidence and spot quack claims. Have an item you'd like us to test? Send an e-mail to health@msnbc.com.



Tiny stair-climber steps up your workout

Posted: Wednesday, July 22, 2009 8:21 PM

by Diane Mapes, contributing writer

 

What it is: Stamina InStride Electronic Stepper, $69.99.

What it claims to do: According to the manufacturer, the InStride Electronic Stepper is a lightweight exercise machine that offers a great cardiovascular workout for people who are limited on space. At just 20 pounds, the Stepper can be used anywhere – while watching TV, while on the phone, while at work – and it can even be tucked “into a workout bag to take along.” The machine’s resistance helps work your calves, thighs and buttocks as well as your core, while the aerobic aspect of the stepper “helps you burn calories and fat.”

Image: Stamina InStride Electronic Stepper
Stamina Products, Inc.
Stamina InStride Electronic Stepper

Our experience:  I’ve always had a hard time working out at the gym without some kind of mental stimulation. IPods just don’t cut it for me; I need conversation, a good book or a TV to keep me from thinking about how boring it is walking, striding or bike riding to nowhere. Unfortunately, my new gym is one of those places where everybody’s plugged in and the closed-captioned TVs are all tuned to sports channels. And yes, I’ll say it: I’m too vain to wear my reading glasses (which have a tendency to fog up once I get going anyway). As a result, I’ve been hitting the gym less and less, opting for 3- or 4-mile walks a few times a week instead. But is that enough? Not according to a study in the Archives of Internal Medicine that says women trying to lose weight need to exercise 55 minutes a day, five days a week.

So I decided to try bringing the gym home and set up an electronic stair-stepper in the middle of my living room, where it would be impossible to avoid (but easily tucked into a closet should company happen by). Assembly was a snap – or rather a couple of snaps: I simply had to insert a metal wheel into the base, thread the metal cable around it, then pop the electronic meter (which gives you a read-out of your time, calories and strides per minute) into place on top. Being mechanically maladroit, I worked up a sweat just putting the thing together, but I managed to get it up and running in about 10 minutes. Sneakers on – yes, you need to wear shoes – and I was ready to roll.

Unlike the stair-steppers at the gym, this one had no handrails, which gave me pause at first. It’s not that I’m unbalanced, but I have been known to fall over while tying a shoe. To keep from freaking out about losing my balance, I put a chair next to the contraption and soon I was stepping away. Or rather, I was clomping away – it took a few minutes to figure out how to keep the pedals from knocking into the floor. Once I leaned forward and stepped up my pace, though, I was pumping like a piston. Having injured myself by overzealousness in the past, I started off slowly, doing five minutes a couple of times a day. Soon, though, I was able to bump that up to 10, then 15, then 20 or so, easily folding these quick bursts of cardio into my normally sedentary day (I work at home and often spend 12 hours a day on the computer). Since I could watch TV or chat on the phone while I was exercising (I wouldn’t advise business calls; the heavy breathing can be disconcerting), my workouts went by quickly with none of the mind-numbing boredom I used to feel at the gym. And being hands-free meant I could work my arms at the same, either with bicep curls, tricep extensions, or, if I was feeling particularly upbeat, cheers. One other fun side note: since I was exercising alone, there was no need to make myself presentable or put on special gym clothes. I used my stepper wearing in sweatpants as well as a sarong and sneakers (not a look I’d risk outside the confines of my living room).

What the experts say:  According to Dr. Sarah M. Speck, director of the Center for CardioVascular Wellness at Swedish Medical Center in Seattle, this kind of exercise equipment offers a two-fold benefit. “If you move the muscles between your waist and your knees for 20-30 minutes a day, you have very beneficial effects on your metabolism and your cardiovascular health in addition looking better in your jeans,” she says. Blood pressure and cholesterol go down, blood sugar is improved and you might just lose a few pounds, since “these are big muscles and they use up a lot of calories.” But the stair-stepper may not be for everyone, and not just those people who are over 250 pounds (the weight limit set by the manufacturer). “Older individuals or anyone with a balance issue should make sure this is something that their doctor approves,” says Speck. People with knee problems also will want to clear it with their doctor before hopping aboard.

 

Starting slow is the way to go, says Speck, and yes, a chair next to the contraption is “not a bad idea since you don’t have any handrails.” Once you’re up and running, though, she says you can either do short spurts (15 to 30 minutes) on a daily basis for good cardiovascular health or long stretches (45 minutes or so) every other day to tone. Whatever your goal (mine is a bit of both), Speck says the stair-stepper can “absolutely” help improve cardiovascular health and aid in weight loss, primarily because of its convenience. “You can do it front of the television; you can do it while you’re waiting for dinner to cook,” she says. “While you’ll get the most benefit doing that 30 minutes all at once, anything is better than sitting on your duff.”

 

Bottom line:  I used the InStride Electronic Stepper for about four weeks and while I haven’t noticed any changes in how my jeans fit, I can say that having this handy contraption in the house has definitely been a boon. It’s convenient, easy to use and for the most part, fairly quiet (an odd squeak has developed in the last few days and this time, it’s not me). The time, calorie and strides-per-minute read-outs are a bit confusing since they rotate through the small screen, but it’s easy enough to figure out how many minutes you’re spending on the thing. As far as I can tell, 10 minutes burns about 130 calories, something that comes to mind at night when I start thinking about grabbing that after-dinner snack (I’ve found positioning the stepper between me and the kitchen helps overcome these moments, too). Coupled with my brisk evening and weekend walks, this device seems to have plugged the big gaping hole in my fitness routine. And it’s saved me money. I just called and cancelled that gym membership I wasn’t using.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I bought and returned two of these.  I used it for about two weeks and then parts of the rubber melted through from being so hot.  I have yet to find a mini-stepper that doesn't fall apart from regular use.
The price has gone up $10.
I've had one of these for a few years and it is so convenient. Using my treadmill can be like going to the gym.If you use a couple of small 3 or 5 pound weights in each hand while you are stepping, it seems to help with the balance.
There is no way the device could have you burning 130 calories in 10 minutes.  Go to a gym and use any professional piece of equipment and set it to an effort level that burns 780 calories an hour.  The difference will be immediately and dramatically apparent!
Well, it sounds like it would be nice to have on those too hot or cold to walk outside days.  However (and this is minor but...) when I clicked the link the price is $69.99 and not the $59.99 this article says it is.
The link has the price at $10 higher than listed...
When you click on the link the price is actually $69.99.  Wonder if that is price gauging because of the article.  Very telling...
JUST AN FYI - I clicked on you link and the product is selling for $69.95, $10 more than you state.
Found on Amazon.com:

By  X. kuang "JK" (S Cal. USA)
After 2 weeks using it for 4-5 times per week & 45 minutes each time, this unit works great. The squeaking noise was little annoying but it went away after I WD-40ed it. For those of you couldn't figure out how to oil this thing, the cable connectors were creating the squeaking sound. Find the two cable ends & just WD-40 them, the sound should go away. Comment Comment (1) | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you?  Yes No (Report this)
I have one of these too and I LOVE the convenience. You can 'speed up' kind of like spinning when you lean lightly on a chair or sofa back in front of you. then back to jumping jack or marching arm motions or curls or whatever to change it up. Focus on different muscle groups too, glutes, thighs, hamstrings, abs...it moves the workout around. Try it!
This "article" reads more like a well-placed ad than an actual article or review. How many times does the reader need to put down the gym?
I have this device and although I don't use it for weight loss, it does add to the cardio.  20 minutes does increase the heart-rate and after 45 minutes you can feel it in  your glutes big-time.  It does squeak and the electronic timer thing is a waste.

As for the gym, Beth, what do they offer that you cannot find in nature for free?  Gym's are for suckers and people who want other's to look see how good they look.
Range of motion. Nuff said
as for the price...WalMart has the same thing for $48.
Its called California Stepper
I own one of these I am in Iraq and our rooms are very small so it does fit in quite comfortabley-after you work 10 to 12 hours a day there are days that you don't feel up to going to the gym.  You can alsoget up in the morning and use it.
It works great when you all you feel like doing is watching a movie.  The gym is free of charge but still you are on a time limit on some of the equipment. I was glad that was able to have this ent to me.
The reality is: All well-made equipment is good- if you use it. While this piece may have its benefits, other pieces have different benefits. The key is to exercise intensely, no matter what the form.

Ray Salomone, Personal Trainer and Wellness Activist
Skeptical, it is possible for the device to burn 130 calories/10 minutes, though it would be a hard workout. On the Precor Elliptical at the gym I regularly hit 840/hour as my target. It just depends on how hard you work out, not necessarily the size of the device. I have not used this one, so I would not be able to say definitively. Unless you have used it, you would not be able to either.
Addendum to my previous comment: I have the 'cheapie' version of the stepper. I just checked at Walmart and you can still get one there. It's called the "Gold's Gym Stepper" and goes for $38.77. That makes it almost disposable for some people. (not for me...I'm a senior citizen on Social Security) It is so convenient to keep in a place where you can watch TV so you won't be bored. I'm not trying to sell anything but I am trying to say that as we age, we need to keep the body moving. I have arthritus in my spine and I try to safely exercise. I don't want to end up like my mother, all crouched over an in pain. One other thing about this cheaper model...it can also be adjusted for pressure. Why not give it a try at this price??
If, after four weeks of use, the author of this article hasn't noticed any difference from using this machine, then really, what is the benefit? Just feeling better about yourself psychologically is not why people buy these contraptions.
I've had my mini-stepper with a handrail from Sharper Image for many years now. I use it 3 to 4 times a week for 20-25 minutes. I'm 54 years old and weigh only 135 pounds at almost 5 feet 7 inches. In addition to my stability ball, light handweights, walking and stretching, I have a complete workout program that keeps me in good shape for my age.
I saw this at Walmart and I almost bought it, but did not. I use the stairclimber at the gym for 40 mins a session. The reason why I didn't buy it is because you can't move up levels. At the gym, I started at Level 4 and I am now at Level 9. With this, you can't track your progress. I think it's great if you are a beginner, and you used to be a couch potato but for someone that does advanced exercises, it's not all that.
Climbing REAL Stairs 3-5 times a week is Cheaper & Far More Exercise than a $70+ Exercise Machine! Also, Better to Park FARTHER AWAY & WALK More EVERYDAY; REMEMBER, 10000 STEPS/Day Or MORE Should Be Your GOAL Each & Every DAY To FEEL Better, LOSE Weight, and Tone MUSCLES! Live EVERY Day BETTER Than The DAY BEFORE! HAPPY TRAILS To YOU! Looking GOOD, AMERICA...
I bought mine at walmart only $29.00
Why do writer that nobody's ever heard of insist on making the writing all about them?!? The 2nd, 3rd, and 4th paragraphs are almost completely about HER! We don't care about your body issues, your clumsiness, your eyesite, your vanity, your laziness. Just write about the equipment--a real evaluation.
Things like these are great if you are doing your home workout routines or on vacation doing the hotel room workout. Other wise its the gym hands down

www.stayfitbug.com
Hmmm. To imply that this gadget is a good substitute for a gym is ridiculous. Go to gym for 55 mins five days a week, as recommended in the article. Do some cardio classes along with strength training. I guarantee you will be healthier AND your jeans will fit better after four weeks.

In my opinion this thing looks like another cheap piece of exercise equipment that will soon remain in the closet (luckily it fits). The author, Diane, needs to do a follow up article in a year.
I had one of these but a different brand.  I used it everyday for about 2 months and then the cable broke.
I bought one of these similar things at Salvation Army and it gets really hot.  It starts to smell really bad too.  They need to find a way for it to not get so hot, maybe with better lubrication.  It also started making noise too and I tried the WD-40 thing and it stopped but the smell was overpowering still. Save your money and just get a timer, a small spongy pad to run on to protect you knees and just run in place.  A half hour is a good start and you will burn more calories than this thing and you can same your money too.  I have a Wii fit and that is what I use and it tells me how many miles I go.  If you don't have one already just do the cheaper way with out it.
Quote "I used the InStride Electronic Stepper for about four weeks and while I haven’t noticed any changes in how my jeans fit"

So it was completely useless then. Zero impact, zip,  nothing, nada. If you didn't see an impact, how could you possibly give this device a positive review?
If you can read or hold a conversation while exercising, I don't believe you are getting much of a workout.
I went to check this out, but the product is actually $69.99, not $59.99.
I too have purchsed two of these units and returned them.The bolts were literally cut through after 8 days for the first and 2 days for the second. Though they broke down quickly, being able to exercise even a little during the down time at work is great. I'm a nurse.
I had this exact model and it broke after less then two months of vigorous usage. Unfortunately, it was a piece that was welded on so I couldn't fix it. If you're looking for a real workout at home, you're better off spending a little more money on some quality equipment
You can listen to books on an ipod.  If you don't want to pay for them you can check out books on CD at your local library and upload them to your itunes.  Personally, I am a podcast junkie and they are free.  If you find some you really like they are a great way to pass the time while working out.  
Quote "I used the InStride Electronic Stepper for about four weeks and while I haven’t noticed any changes in how my jeans fit"

The reason you have not noticed any change in how your jeans fit it because you must incorporate healthy eating habits too. There is a recipe for weightloss and  that is eat right and exercise. Plus 55 minutes per day 5 times a week of exercise.
The author should not be able to have a conversation or read a book if she's working out hard enough. You have to get your heart rate up to a target level and maintain it for 20-40 minutes, and interval training is the key.  Interval training is the key for fat loss, relying on muscle strength and not relying on the momentum of a device like an elliptical machine to do the work for you. Skipping rope, doing body weight exercises, using heavy duty elastic bands/rubber cord type of exercises, dance, martial arts training are some of the exercises you can do at home if you don't want to go to a gym.  You can also set up your own home gym using common household items.
I lived in japan over 3 years ago and bought a mini-stepper for $20. it's hard plastic and metal and works great.Dunno aobut this one advertised but i use the mini-stepper when i'm watching TV (i can't sit still for most of my shows). i'd advise people to buy something like this
I don't think these things work i had one]:
Not skeptical....I use the Precor elipitical machine at the gym 6 days a week, I burn around 425 calories in a 30 minute MODERATE cardio workout. The machine will deliver based on the users effort.
does anyone know why my meter stays at zero all the time on my mini stepper, it turns on but never counts
I bought a different brand at Walmart and I love it (besides the squeak). It's pretty small and that's very convenient in my apartment. When I first got it I used it 5 days a week for about 30 min but I have dropped down to a 2-3 days a week. After about 2 months I noticed my jeans really do fit better and adding more shape to my legs. I didn't exercise at all before this, so I would say it is a great start for beginners.
Had a more basic version that I kept under my desk at work. Each day, instead of curling up my legs and not getting any movement, I did a slow but steady workout of stepping. I followed this up with taking the dogs for a long walk as soon as I got home and lost about 20 lbs. in three months. My diet was a little less fast food but basically the same.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):