ABOUT THIS BLOG

Does that new health or fitness product really do what it says it will? Let us find out for you. MSNBC.com writers and editors will periodically try out various products, devices and gadgets and report back their experiences. And experts will help us assess the evidence and spot quack claims. Have an item you'd like us to test? Send an e-mail to health@msnbc.com.



Vacuum plumps lips - if it doesn't suck them off

Posted: Thursday, October 15, 2009 2:13 PM

By Melissa Dahl

What it is: JolieLips Lip Plumping & Enhancement System, $27.95.

What it claims to do: It’s supposed to give you full, Angelina Jolie-style lips – and I’m guessing that the name “JolieLips” is meant to not-so-subtly push the Angie connection. The Web site promises that this device make your lips “fuller and sexier” without using injections, causing pain or “nonsense tingling cream” to do so.

Image: Lip Enhancement Kit
skymall.com

My experience: When the device arrived in the mail, I excitedly ripped the box open. And then promptly closed it. Something about an oversized, oddly-shaped pump arriving in an unmarked box made the whole thing seem vaguely dirty, and I guiltily looked around my apartment to make sure my roommate wasn’t home. She wasn’t. It was clearly time to pump things up.

The instructions say to relax your lips and give the softball-sized doodad several short squeezes for 10 seconds. (They do not, however, say how to deal with the disgusting amount of slobber that will result from using a suction device on your mouth.)

It did hurt a little, but I sort of expected that – I was, after all, essentially applying a hand-pump vacuum to my lips. But I remembered it also took me a while to get used to the sting from plumping glosses like Lip Venom. Plus, the pain seemed beside the point, because it appeared that JolieLips actually delivered on its promise. My lips really did look fuller – and redder – than they normally do. I was so happy with the results at that point that I tried it again a few hours later, since the instructions suggest using the pump several times a day. (Side note: Really? Several times a day? Pulling a gigantic pump out of your purse and affixing it to your face isn’t quite the same thing as subtly reapplying lip gloss.)

But when I looked in the mirror the next morning, my lips looked … odd. To be precise: It looked like I had been punched in the mouth. The center of both my lower and upper lips had turned a deep bluish-purple that refused to be hidden, no many how many layers of lipstick I slathered on. My lips were visibly bruised that entire weekend, meaning I had to endure hilarious taunts from my friends. (“What up, Blue Lips?” and “Heh, did you just eat a blue raspberry Otter Pop?" were among my favorites.)

I do wonder if I was a little too aggressive the first time I tried JolieLips, because a few weeks later I summoned the courage to try it again (very, very gently this time) and didn’t experience any bruising.

What the expert says: Plastic surgeon Dr. John Canady said he wasn’t surprised by my experience with JolieLips. He explained that the pump creates a vacuum around the lips, and “this negative pressure is a type of trauma to the lip that causes it to swell,” says Canady, who is the president of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons. While JolieLips could cause fuller lips, he noted “so could getting punched in the mouth.”

He said it probably could work, albeit briefly; you really would have to commit to using this thing several times a day, as the instructions suggest. Canady did say that it would be helpful if there was some way to adjust or keep track of exactly how much pressure you’re applying.

“There probably is some place in that pressure curve where you can induce a little bit of short-term lip swelling if you‘re going out on a date or something and you just want to pump that up a bit without them getting bruised,” says Canady, who’s also a professor of plastic surgery at the University of Iowa in Iowa City.

Bottom line: Fuller lips just weren’t worth the physical and emotional pain I experienced with JolieLips. I’ll stick with my lip gloss.

More on skin and beauty:
15 ultimate age erasers
In lust for lashes, few bat an eye at odd risks
Solving embarrassing skin problems



 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Hey....I got one of those things too and I have to say, they don't work!
Why not just accept the lips nature gave you!!
Could I be more clueless about women than I think I am?  Why do they think that unless they have a certain body shape, facial shape, lip shape, eyelash length, and/or skin texture that they are essentially unworthy of love, respect, and consideration?  Is it years of being educated to think in a way that has made them what they are now?

Men seem not to care in the least about these things.  If we are fate, big deal; there's more of us to love.  If we are not handsome, so what; we'll keep you safe by scaring away the robbers at night.  If we lack social graces, who cares; forests are not cut down and roads are not paved by tea sipping sybarites.

I guess it boils down to what one believes about himself or herself.  No amount of grooming, cutting, or reshaping makes the inner person any different.  Being happy does not mean becoming attached to Mr. or Miss Right.  The inner happiness has to be there first.
LOLOLOLOLOLMAO!!!!!!
LOLOLOLOLOLMAO!!!!!!
A lot of women I see on TV look like they have been punched in the mouth and the chin. Who decided that Baboon lips and a Letterman chin are sexy? They aren't.  That pointy chin is really weird anyway.  A deformed jaw bone?  Lips like they have been eating poison ivy?  What is wrong with women that they think these things are sexy?  Men don't think so!
It really is a shame that most "modern" women remain totally clueless about the things that make them physically appealing and attractive to us men. It seems that most women think that if they don't weigh a certain weight, or wear a certain size, or if they don't expose some breast or tail, that us men won't notice them at all. In fact, the exact opposite is true. Most of us men desire women who respect and love themselves for who they are and not who they wish they looked like or acted like. Someone who has to take the time to "plump" their lips, inject chemicals, and/or insert any number of fake devices with the intent of projecting a truly fake sense of beauty, is really exposing their own insecurity with themselves. I say, get over yourselves already, ok? True beauty is never defined by what you look like, but by who you are inside.
People Should be satisfied the way GOD made them. What looks good on one person may not be attractive on you.
You ahould be satisfied the way God made you. Some like thick lips and some don't. I have observed some that had their lips altered and it looks repulsive.
A female friend of our neighbor's is one of those BOTX, Restalyn(sp?) people.  Her face and lips are always bruised from countless injections.  When she first gets the shots she won't see anyone for days, until it is all healed.  Perhaps we should recommend "JolieLips" for her!

Other than that comment, I think the whole thing is ridiculous.  There are people starving without homes and all you can think about is your wrinkles or thin lips.  Give me a break!
I agree with Robert. Most of my friends are guys and think it's hilarious/ a turn off or disgusting that women would actually try to do something like this. The only thing it's good for is attracting nicknames like "Fish face" or getting a visit from Human Resources if you know what I mean...
There are times when I wonder if the human race has the right to declare itself an intelligent species. The "case" covering you soul is only there for the functional purpose of allowing you to exist in this illusory plane, when you go back to your real life it is removed, when you come back here another one is provided that befits your task for that existence, and so on through eternity. If people would just get it right, more progress could be made with less wasted time. Use your illusion to good purpose, not self-aggrandizement.
I have full lips. so, i have NEVER understood this obession. sometimes, my lips seriously get in my way.
The only side affetc is that when gravity takes over, your ass size TRIPLES..........
Would love to meet the whack-a-doodle who thought this one up!
Thank you, gentlemen! Women who try too hard usually end up looking like clowns anyway. Gotta love yourself!
I think Angelina's lips are very scary!
I would never consider doing something painful to "enhance" anything. My husband loves me like I am, flaws and all. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and like rdefazio said, looks don't change the person inside.
Ladies & Gents - anything, and I do mean ANYTHING, that employs suction to enlarge anything is not ment to be used on the human body.  The thing you want enlarged actually swells up due to the blood forced to the surface - in other words you bruised it.  Not attractive.
You all are hypocrites!  I wonder what are some of  things that you people indulge in; hair dying, Color contact lens, or just plain old make-up? Or is that you have just settled with the fact that you're unattractive and can't do much of anything to change it? Does sitting around awaiting the opportunity to take pot-shots at those who enjoy enhancing their beauty ease your pain?  Jealousy has to be one of the most unrewarding emotions there is, so why allow yourself to be subjected to it? Keep your remarks regarding the efforts of others to enhance their looks/beauty to yourself.
How stupid to even try this. Of course the lips swell because they have been damaged by the tissue being subjected to trauma.

What is so great about big rubber lips anyway?
I bought one of these for my lips since they were kind of thin.  I am afraid to go back to Alaska until the swelling goes down.
Sounds like little Bill C. did a little enhancing himself and is defensive. It's okay lil buddy, its not the size of the ship but the skill of the skipper ;)
WTF.........I swear why would anyone do this crap to themselves?  People be sane.....think!  
As a male, I never really understood the infatuation some women had with big lips.  I'm not attracted to that look at all.
I think all these comments are hilarious. Of course, people should feel free to do what they enjoy, and all these remarks about true beauty being of the soul, while true, do denote a certain self-righteousness that is unappealing. Come on folks, let's be real: some people indulge in plumping up their lips, while others indulge in Viagra to pump up something else or by underwire support bras to enhance the size of their boobs, etc. Since this is a free country - not [yet] ruled by Sharia Law, we don't have the right to judge others for making their lips look plump, their hair look black (instead of grey), or their asses look smaller (by wearing a girdle). So cheer up, folks, and find something else get riled up about.
How hilarious! When I was a child, my sister and I would  place a drinking glass over our mouth and suck the air out of it, making our lips red--and "plump" ugly. Our mother admonished us that if we kept it up we'd disfigure our faces! For sure!
How hilarious! When I was a child, my sister and I would  place a drinking glass over our mouth and suck the air out of it, making our lips red--and "plump" ugly. Our mother admonished us that if we kept it up we'd disfigure our faces! For sure!
Actually,Angelina Jolie's lips look totally unnatural; as do Julia Roberts'. Now, both seem to be all mouth/lips.  I saw a "natural" photo of Julia R., she is quite a homely woman without all that makeup.  As for Jolie, I doubt we'll ever see her without her full regiment of makeup.  Think your lips are too thin, try the old-fashioned method, gently bite on your lips for a few seconds, they will NOT swell out of control and you can do this throughout the day without anyone really noticing.  A little makeup can always enhance our appearance, too much makeup can make us look like clowns! Botox (sp) keeps your facial muscles from moving; hence that inability to really smile genuinely.  Examples:  Jolie, Parton, and Nancy Pelosi!  A special thanks to the gentlemen here who prefer the inner beauty to the fake beauty!
Imagine if they re-branded it with a Mick Jagger endorsement and sold it as a Rolling Stones promotional product--just put a sticker with the lips logo on it and watch them fly off the shelves...
(Hey, if they'll buy concert tickets at those insane prices, they'll probably drop the cash for one of these things too!)
Why can't women figure out that men really don't care what you look like.
We have one thing on our mind, all the time, and your lips don't make any difference.
Well DUH this thing doesnt work!!  Have you seen the advertising picture?!  When i first saw it at my hair salon, it was OBVIOUS that they photoshopped Angelina Jolie's lips onto that model's face.. NOBODY can have or get Angelina's lips... God gave those to her.  
Ok first off I have seen picks of Angelina Jolie as a child and she has always had the same lips. She has her mothers mouth and her brother has the same lips. Personally I think her lips are beautiful ON HER. Not everyone looks proportioned right with full lips.  I naturally have very full lips and so does a couple of my brothers as did my dad.  I think they look great on me and my husband can't look at my mouth without getting excited.  To each their own.  Maybe some women want full lips because their husband likes full lips.  The guy who said men don't care about that stuff is full of crap.  Most women have complexes because of the things men say about saggy boobs or "look at that chick with no tits"  Girls pay attention to what men say and do and we have all heard their comments about fat chicks and no BUTT and flat chested. So don't blame on the industry.  It's men women want to appeal to and they are the reason women put them selves through this.  I could easily sit here and critizise others along with you, I happen to be happy with the way I look but that wasn't always the case. When I was a teen I was 5'4 and 115 pounds with nice breast...did I like myself nooo why? because girls were always saying things like "ewwwww don't sit so close i can fill your bones." I ate constantly to get plumper, I was always envious of apple butts and thick legs...I thought i looked great until those comments from jealous thicker girls stung my young and fragile feelings at that age.  It's what people hear others say about others that effect their own opinion of themselves it's not the industry.  The industry just capitalizes on the already existant insecurities. So stop pointing fingers at others and sit back and think about the harsh things you all have said about someone in the presense of another.  Maybe you have said hey honey look at that fat @ss to your girlfriend and she has thought "hmmm she is about the same size as me."
Oh Donna from Vista, You are so absolutely correct. This is exactly why the majority of women want to do these aweful things to their bodies. Even though it is a security issue it was totally reninforced by what we women have heard all our lives. True to that the majority of men tend to look at our mouths because they are truely only interested in one thing and if they are fuller it draws the guys in like a bee to honey they seem to be stuck on the thought of sucking on them all day until they meet you again. So yes you guys with all your vain thoughts and own conceived ideas of what is the most beautiful woman you can dangle on your arm for your other friends to see has caused almost all of the way women try so hard to get your undying attention not for just a day but for everyday. So that is why they go through the all the cutting and permament poofing so they can look nice everyday and maybe you will be proud and not want to look at another woman. Of course it is in mans nature to check it out no matter what you look like girls. Remember girls that although its true that the bears are drawn to the beehives its only the sweetness inside that keeps them coming back. So lighten up on yourselves. There are always going to be cheaters and users, but if you watch that person for about six months he will show his true colors. It doesn't take long to find out if he is a player. You don't want someone who doesn't want you the real you anyway. So if after the six months he still wants to be beside you and he is still telling you that he wants you with him forever you can probably believe him. This means he loves the whole you just like you are bad, ugly, and sweet. Good Luck to all


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):